Photo via Plugged In

Make the most of your Amazon Prime membership.

As with all of the major streaming services, Amazon has its pros and cons. Among the pros are the TV library and access to new movies. Digging into the movie catalog shows that the streaming service still has a ways to go, especially if you compare Amazon vs. Netflix or Hulu. But fear not, there are still enough movies available for free (if you have an Amazon Prime account) to whip up a list of recommendations.

The best movies on Amazon Prime in October 2017

1) Fargo

Fargo is arguably the pinnacle of the Coen Brothers’ oeuvre. But that’s a matter of opinion. What isn’t up for debate is the greatness of Frances McDormand’s iconic performance as Marge Gunderson. This tale of a crime committed by a bunch of idiots and the pregnant police chief smarter than everyone else is everything that is great about the Coens. It’s darkly funny, sharply written, unflinching, and impeccably acted. Fargo is a classic that is as fresh today as it was 20 years ago.

best amazon movies : Fargo Photo via IMDb

2) No Country for Old Men

Aided by numerous late-night cable viewings No Country has ascended to the top of my Coen Brothers power rankings. I’m hard-pressed to think of a more impeccably crafted thriller. It’s visceral, unflinching, and even has a few moments for philosophizing (courtesy of Tommy Lee Jones’ lawman). Javier Bardem’s Anton Chigurh has ascended into the pantheon of great villains, and it’s well-deserved. Chirgurh is precise in everything he does, and his expressionless stare pierces through the screen and into your soul. But don’t underestimate Josh Brolin, who matches Bardem’s preternatural calm with his own, but with enough cracks in the tough exterior to let his nerves show.

best drama movies on netflix and amazon prime: No Country for Old Men Screengrab via Movieclips Trailer Vault/YouTube

3) Moonlight

Barry Jenkins’ Best Picture-winning film tells the story of Chiron in three parts as he grows up and comes to terms with his sexuality and learning to be comfortable in his own skin. Chiron may be black and gay, and the movie’s focus may be narrow, but its themes are universal. There are moments so empathetic that I’m welling up a little just thinking about it. The cast is remarkable, from the three actors who play Chiron to Naomie Harris, Janelle Monae, and Oscar winner Mahershala Ali. Its status as one of the lowest grossing Best Picture winners means a ton of people need to catch up with it.

best amazon movies : moonlight Screengrab via A24/YouTube

4) There Will Be Blood

Paul Thomas Anderson is arguably the best American filmmaker going, and his 2007 film is as representative of his work as any of his masterpieces. Daniel Day-Lewis gives an all-time best performance as Daniel Plainview, a miner-turned-oil prospector with unlimited ambition. It tells the specific story of California’s oil boom, but it’s also timeless. It’s big, it’s sprawling, it’s messy, it’s a must-see movie. Plus, any movie that makes something as innocuous as a milkshake into an iconic cinematic moment is worth reckoning with it.

best movies on amazon prime : there will be blood Screengrab via Movieclips Trailer Vault/YouTube

5) Paterson

Every day for bus driver Paterson (Adam Driver) is exactly the same, and every day is also sublimely unique. Making wonderful use of repetition and recurring imagery, indie legend Jim Jarmusch’s latest shows how beauty can be found everywhere, if only you bother to look. Anchored by Driver’s understated performance, Paterson is a celebration of the creative impulse and its ability to impart mystery and import to even the most innocuous of things. —David Wharton

best movies on amazon prime: paterson Screengrab via FilmTrailerZone/YouTube

6) The Machinist

This mid-aughts indie from director Brad Anderson began the run of Christian Bale, Shape-Shifting Method Actor. Bale famously dropped down to 120 pounds by following a diet of water, an apple, and a cup of coffee per day in order to play an insomniac machinist. After an accident on the job, Trevor Reznik (Bale) goes on a quest for answers. The film is weird, paranoid, and tense, and it only gets weirder and even more intense as it goes on.

The Machinist Screengrab via YouTube Movies/YouTube

7) Inside Llewyn Davis

If you’re following these recommendations in order, then this is the capper to a Coen Brothers evening. Llewyn Davis plays like one of the title character’s songs: haunting, sorrowful, and ultimately wonderful. Oscar Isaac gives a lived-in performance that rings so true you’ll be disappointed that he doesn’t have a blues side project going. The movie takes place over the course of a week, with Llewyn playing his songs and trying to grab his big break—if he could just get out of his own way long enough to let it happen. We’re getting to the point where we’ll start seeing “best of the decade” lists coming together, and this film is sure to appear on many lists. Many people skipped it during its 2013 release, and if you’re one of those people, or if you haven’t seen it in awhile, it’s time to rectify that.

8) Manchester by the Sea

Manchester by the Sea is a tough watch, what with it revolving around a handyman, Lee (Casey Affleck, who won an Oscar for his performance), dealing with his brother’s (Kyle Chandler) death. Lee has to take in his nephew, Patrick (Academy Award-nominated Lucas Hedges) and grapple with his past failings. Despite the gloomy setting and gloomier subject matter, Manchester has a wicked funny bone. Writer-director Kenneth Lonergan specializes in crafting sincere characters and dialogue so authentic you’ll want to start a GoFundMe to help Lee and Lucas stay afloat while they figure things out.

best movies on amazon prime : Manchester by the sea Screengrab via Movieclips Trailers/YouTube

9) Ex Machina

Writer-director Alex Garland is one of the best sci-fi minds going in film. He favors heady stories that creep you out and his debut behind the camera is no different. Aside from launching the most popular film GIF of 2015 (Oscar Isaac’s red-light soaked dance number), Ex Machina established Garland as a directorial force.

Best movies on Amazon Prime: Ex Machina Photo via Ex Machina

10) Before Sunrise

The Before trilogy is one of the best in all of American cinema. Jesse (Ethan Hawke) and Celine (Julie Delpy) are strangers who make the most of a chance encounter on a train and turn it into a night neither will ever forget. Hawke and Delpy have the kind of chemistry that just makes you happy to watch them together, whether they’re casually strolling down a riverwalk or having deep philosophical conversations. Like the best relationships, there’s nowhere else you’d rather be when you’re with Jesse and Celine. Director Richard Linklater has a knack for taking everyday occurrences and turning them into movie magic. It’s a miracle that Linklater, Delpy, and Hawke were able to make one movie this romantic and honest, let alone two others. Take the plunge; you won’t regret it.

11) Before Sunset

The middle chapter of the immaculate Before trilogy takes place in almost real time as Jesse (Ethan Hawke) and Celine (Julie Delpy) reunite nine years after their night together in Vienna. Jesse is on a book tour and, after an appearance, he and Celine walk and talk before Jesse’s flight home in a couple hours. The conversation, a hallmark of the series, is enduringly great, and Hawke and Delpy are as good as ever. With some character history for Jesse and Celine (and the audience), to wade through, the stakes are significantly higher than the will-they-won’t-they of Before Sunrise. I love the Before films so much, and the Sunset may be the best of the set.

best amazon prime movies : Before Sunset Screengrab via Criterion

12) The One I Love

This low-key sci-fi mind-bender focuses on a couple (Mad Men’s Elisabeth Moss and Mark Duplass) getting more than they bargained for during a weekend getaway. Moss and Duplass come across clones of themselves, and the more they interact with their alternates, the less stable their relationship becomes. As the twists and confusion increase, the emotional stakes rise and become more intriguing. It’s the kind of movie that would have coasted on its cool concept in lesser hands, but McDowell and writer Justin Lader, with a stellar cast, concocted something that will linger after it’s over. If you’re a fan of Shane Carruth’s high-brow mind-benders, make some time for Charlie McDowell’s directorial debut.

13) Invasion of the Body Snatchers

Amazon has a few different versions of Invasion of the Body Snatchers, so make sure you select this one and not the awful and awfully boring one with Nicole Kidman and Daniel Craig. The Don Siegel-directed version may be 60 years old, but it remains one of the better iterations of this story. In a movie where people are replaced by aliens, sometimes old-school movie-making charm is the thing that will put it over the top.

best movies on amazon prime : invasion of the Body snatchers Screengrab via glows/YouTube

14) Swiss Army Man

It’s a damn shame that so few people saw this movie in theaters. The premise is kitschy enough that most people dismissed it outright, but now that Swiss Army Man is streaming, hopefully it will find the audience it deserves. It’s about a man (Paul Dano) and the dead body he befriends (Daniel Radcliffe). The friendship that blossoms between the two is hilarious, charming, and far more emotionally involving than you expect. The story is laced with enough juvenile humor to appeal to the inner kid in everyone, but the ace in the hole is its highly affecting emotional drama. The movie is a celebration of life anchored by truly great performances from Dano and Radcliffe.

15) The VVitch

Writer-director Robert Eggers spent years meticulously researching 17th-century New England and getting his debut film made, then a year showing it at film festivals before its proper release in 2016. The patience and dedication to authenticity comes through in the final product. Eggers’ film is patient, atmospheric as hell, and deeply unsettling. It’s about a Puritan family expelled from their community and the trouble they encounter living on their own. The vision is uncompromising and distinct, qualities that have drawn excited comparisons to no less that Stanley Kubrick and Paul Thomas Anderson. That puts an unenviable amount of pressure on Eggers’ follow up, whenever that comes out, but his craft is undeniable and worth getting worked up over.

READ MORE:

16) Monster

Writer-director Bryan Bertino made a strong impression on horror fans with his 2008 home invasion film The Strangers. The Monster is a different kind of horror film. It’s about a mother and daughter on a road trip forced to confront a monster, both literal and metaphorical. The movie packs an emotional punch to go along with the scares and the result is a visceral viewing experience. It’s a solid showcase for the film’s star, Zoe Kazan, but an even more impressive display of Bertino’s talent.

best movies on amazon prime : the monster Screengrab via A24/YouTube

17) 99 Homes

Ramin Bahrani’s housing crisis thriller plays as the more serious, less snarky companion to The Big Short. Michael Shannon gives a typically intense and great performance as a real estate broker who’s more shark than human. Andrew Garfield is a struggling family man whose house is foreclosed on by Shannon, before eventually being convinced to work for the man who forced his family to live out of a motel. It’s a story that shows the real-life effects of the housing crisis and how people dealt with it. Sure, it’s exaggerated in places, but that exaggeration isn’t too far from the reality. There are a few eviction scenes that are gripping and heartrending as anything you’ve seen lately.

18) Stardust

Director Matthew Vaughn is a director I go back and forth on. I’m bored by his X-Men movies and can’t even make it through the Kingsman trailer, but I have an inexplicable fondness for Kick-Ass. But the real jewel of his filmography is Stardust, an adaptation of Neil Gaiman’s novel. It’s about a man who promises to retrieve a star from a magical land as a show of commitment to his lady love. The film is as whimsical and fantastical as that description implies without being saccharine, and it’s a blast. The good feeling you get from watching it will linger for a while and we could all stand to smile more.

19) The Lobster

Greek director Yorgos Lanthimos tells his satirical stories in such a deadpan way that it’s easy to (wrongfully) write his work off as detached nihilism. His style is an acquired taste, but if you’re willing to take the chance, his films are worth the investment. The Lobster is about a single man (a schlubby, sad-sack, terrific Colin Farrell) who is forced by the government to check into a hotel, wherein he’ll have 45 days to find a mate or be turned into an animal of his choosing. The first half of the film takes down every aspect of modern-day courtship, while the second half shifts into something more optimistic and, dare I say, romantic. Farrell does some of his best work to date, and the rest of the cast (Rachel Weisz, John C. Reilly, Olivia Colman, and Lea Seydoux, among others) is uniformly excellent.

20) The Handmaiden

If you haven’t seen it yet, stop everything you’re doing and spend the next two-and-a-half hours in Park Chan-wook’s exhilarating The Handmaiden. The movie is chock full of twists and role-reversals and is so much fun that mentioning any story specifics would be unfair. Chan-wook is one of the world’s most entertaining directors, and The Handmaiden is arguably one of his best. Everything that makes him great is on display here, from the dizzying tonal shifts to the luscious photography, and idiosyncratic indulgences.

amazon prime movies : the handmaiden Screengrab via Magnolia Pictures and Magnet Releasing/YouTube

21) Room

Not The Room, just Room. Drop the “The” and trade Tommy Wiseau for the infinitely more charming Brie Larson. Room is based on the bestselling Emma Donahue novel of the same name, and it’s about a woman who was kidnapped and has spent five years living in a room with her son. It’s unquestionably harrowing, but the film opens up in the second half when mom and son (Jacob Tremblay, doing some strong kid acting) regain their freedom. It’s an emotional gauntlet, but one that is worth going through for Larson’s Oscar-winning work.

22) What We Do in the Shadows

This is one of the funniest movies of the last few years and it deserves a much larger fanbase than the small and passionate one it has now. Co-written and co-directed by Taika Waititi and Jemaine Clement, this New Zealand set romp follows the daily lives of a quartet of vampires. Shot mockumentary style, the movie is packed to the fangs with so many jokes that it makes repeat viewings a necessity. Whether hunting for prey, fighting with werewolves, or reuniting with old loves, Waititi and Clement have crafted a pitch-perfect comedy that riffs on well-known mythology and newly created lore with an equal cleverness.

Best movies on Amazon Prime: What We Do in the Shadows Screengrab via Madman Films/YouTube

23) The Fits

The Fits is an evocative coming-of-age story. Newcomer Royalty Hightower enters the pantheon of great child performances with her work as Toni, a girl on the cusp of puberty and trying to make it onto a dance team filled with older, more (apparently) self-assured girls. Making matters worse is the titular affliction that befalls members of the team. The atmosphere is intoxicating, and at a lean 75-minute runtime, The Fits is an ideal choice for someone looking for something new. First-time director Anna Rose Holmer makes a strong impression and establishes herself as one of American cinema’s exciting new voices.

Best movies on Amazon Prime: The Fits Photo by oscopelabs/YouTube

24) Son of Rambow

If you’re in the mood for a movie that will slap a smile on your face and keep in there for two hours, then Son of Rambow is the only choice. It’s about two boys, Will and Lee, who aim to make their own version of Rambo. The boys find something they’ve been missing in both their unlikely friendship and their filmmaking. The film may fall victim to formula occasionally, but the film’s charm and sincerity elevate it to a level where any shortcomings are easy to forgive.

Best movies on Amazon Prime: Son of Ranbow Screengrab via Smeaton Plymouth

25) Big Fan

To anyone who thinks they or someone they know has an unhealthy obsession with sports, I humbly submit Robert Siegel’s Big Fan. Siegel, who wrote The Wrestler, made his directorial debut with this story about a lonely guy and his toxic fandom. That guy is played by Patton Oswalt, who excels as a dramatic actor. Big Fan is the kind of movie where you might think you’re better than the characters, but by the end, you’re completely sucked into their world. You’ll either realize you have a problem or be thankful that you’re not like Oswalt’s character, but either way you’ll be glad you watched Big Fan.

Best movies on Amazon Prime: Big Fan Screengrab via Screen Time/YouTube

26) Knight of Cups

Terence Malick’s films used to have legendary gestation periods, but since Tree of Life came out in 2011, the renowned reclusive director has been churning out movies, with three features and a documentary through 2017. Knight of Cups received an unusually negative reaction despite having its notable champions. Regardless, Malick movies are essential viewing for cinephiles and are worth reckoning with, whether you like them or not. The meandering plot, about a writer doing some soul searching, is a total cliché, but plot is not important in Malick movies. What is important is the experience and being provoked and engaged.

Best Movies on Amazon Prime: Knight of Cups Photo via Roger Ebert

27) Green Room

If you liked Blue Ruin, you should check out writer-director Jeremy Saulnier’s followup, Green Room. A punk band, led by the late Anton Yelchin, stumbles across something they shouldn’t see and end up trapped in a venue in the middle of nowhere. Did I mention that the club is run by neo-Nazis? Well, it is, and the Nazis are led by Patrick Stewart. The band has to fight its way out, and that’s about it for plot summary. The movie is violent and incredibly tense, and the filmmaking and storytelling is as lean, muscular, and vicious as an attack dog.

good amazon prime movies : green room Screengrab vai A24/YouTube

28) Krisha

We’ve all seen enough “family comes together for a holiday and their problems get aired out” movies to know what to expect, but Krisha overcomes expectations to be a worthy entry to the genre. First-time filmmaker Trey Edward Shults focuses his story on the grandmother, Krisha (Krisha Fairchild), a woman whose substance-abuse issues keeps the whole family on edge. The power of the movie comes primarily from Fairchild, who plays Krisha with a ferocity that is hard to look away from.

amazon prime movies : krisha Screengrab via A24/YouTube

29) The Neon Demon

Nicolas Winding Refn’s movies are not for everyone. He makes aggressive, confrontational films that practically dare you to turn them off. But he’s too skilled a craftsman to completely dismiss outright. The Neon Demon is about a young woman (Elle Fanning) breaking into and ascending the ranks in the L.A. modeling world. The movie is a treatise on the male gaze, the perceived vapidity of models, and the dog-eat-dog nature of the industry—or at least the version of the industry depicted here. The good thing about Refn and The Neon Demon is that you’ll know within the first few minutes of the movie if it’s something you want to see.

amazon movies : neon demon Screengrab via Movieclips Trailers/YouTube

READ MORE:

30) The Love Witch

The Love Witch is the kind of movie that many people will dismiss as an homage to an era and genre of film long gone, but it’s more than that. Beyond the bright colors, intentionally stilted line readings, and incredible set decoration lies a movie that engages with thorny ideas about gender roles and relationship dynamics. Written and directed by Anna Biller (who also handled producing, scoring, editing and art design duties), The Love Witch is about a woman using spells and magic to make men fall in love with her, with deadly consequences.

good amazon prime movies : the love witch Screengrab via Movieclips Film Festivals & Indie Films/YouTube

31) The Girl With All the Gifts

This zombie movie has a clever twist. The main character, Melanie (Sennia Nanua), is a middle school-aged student who is a second-generation zombie. That means her and her classmates have zombie instincts but also the ability to think and function like a normal human. It’s the best of both worlds. Or the worst, depending on your approach to life. After a bit of calamity, Melanie ends up on the run with her teacher (Gemma Arterton), overlord doctor (Glenn Close), and some military guys. If you’re a zombie aficionado, Girl is must-see stuff. If you’re understandably tired of the genre, I still encourage you to give this one a shot.

amazon prime movies : the girl with all the gifts Screengrab via Movieclips Trailers/YouTube

32) The Greasy Strangler

I’ll be upfront with you and say right now that The Greasy Strangler isn’t a good movie. It’s more like a gauntlet of bad taste and most people who endure it probably won’t be better off for having done so. The Greasy Strangler arrived as a cult movie and that’s the kind of sensibility it plays to. It’s about an ultra-weird father and son who have inane conversations. The father also slathers his nude body in grease and murders people. There’s cartoonish violence, copious amounts of unpleasant nudity, a catchy synth score, and some hypnotic imagery. This is one best taken in after a few drinks and/or with friends. If nothing else, it’s a memorable experience.

best movies amazon prime : the greasy strangler Screengrab via JoBlo Movie Clips/YouTube

33) The Blackcoat’s Daughter

Writer-director Osgood Perkins descends from horror royalty (he’s the son of Psycho star Anthony Perkins), so it’s not a shock that he makes good horror films. The Blackcoat’s Daughter is a slow-burn story about two girls stuck at their boarding school during winter break. The students, Kat (Kiernan Shipka) and Rose (Lucy Boyton), find the lonely campus becoming increasingly creepy. I’m trying to be vague here because the story isn’t complex, but I think knowing as little as possible going in enhances the experience. The movie is Perkins’ debut, and it establishes a new, exciting voice in horror filmmaking.

best amazon prime movies : the blackcoat's daughter Screengrab via Movieclips Trailers/YouTube

34) Breakdown

Breakdown is a kickass entry in Kurt Russell’s ass-kicking oeuvre. Russell plays a man whose wife goes missing on a road trip and will stop at nothing to get her back. The movie is filled with mind games and great reversals as Russell’s character is constantly having victory snatched from him. Breakdown isn’t the flashiest or best known of Russell’s action films. But it’s as entertaining as any of his classics. At a lean 93 minutes, recommendations don’t get much easier than this.

best movies on amazon prime : breakdown Screengrab via YouTube

35) Anomalisa

Charlie Kaufman is arguably the best American filmmaker going right not. Or the most important. At the very least, he’s the best screenwriter. Anomalisa marks his second directorial effort after the much-praised Synecdoche, New York, and it’s full of the pathos and introspection that have marked much of his work to date. It’s about a lonely man living a pedestrian life who meets someone who breaks up the monotony. But it’s about so much more than just that. Kaufman has written some of the absolute best films of the last 20 years (Being John Malkovich, Adaptation, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind), but he doesn’t get the chance to direct very often, so we have to savor the films we do get from him.

Best movies on Amazon Prime: Anomalisa Photo via Paramount Pictures

Still not sure what to watch? Here are the best Amazon originals, the best documentaries on Amazon Prime, what’s new on Amazon, and the sexiest movies you can stream right now.  

Editor’s note: This article is regularly updated for relevance. 

From Our VICE Partners

Pure, uncut internet. Straight to your inbox.