What’s the best streaming service for your budget?

Photo via Roku/Amazon Amazon Google (Fair Use) Remix by Jason Reed

Here’s what you need to consider when choosing between Chromecast, Roku, and Amazon Fire.

What is the best streaming device for your needs? With Amazon, Roku, and Google offering strong contenders in the streaming device market, making a choice can be difficult. Each of these devices streams video and music via your home internet connection, but the subtle differences between them are important to consider before making a purchase. Here’s what you need to know—and our pick for your best bet. 

Chromecast vs Roku

Chromecast vs Roku Photo via Google

Google Chromecast $35 to $69

For $35, the Google Chromecast 2 might initially seem like the clear winner of the budget streaming wars. Chromecast plugs into your TV’s HDMI port, hiding from sight and keeping your TV area clear of clutter. Unlike its competitors, Google Chromecast does not come with a remote. Instead, you use your Android or iOS device to “cast” your media, selecting apps and content with a swipe of your finger.  

When it comes to streaming options, Chromecast offers all of the basics, including Netflix, Hulu, HBO Now, PlayStation Vue, and Amazon. Streaming quality is standard 1080p HD on the basic Chromecast model, but the $69 Chromecast Ultra supports 4K Ultra HD and HDR.


READ MORE: 


Chromecast has a lot going for it. You can play games, mirror your Android screen, and watch media on your TV, all from the comfort of your sofa. However, it does not come with a remote, meaning if you’re trying to help your parents/grandparents get into the streaming world, they’ll either need a smartphone or to learn a new app just to use it. Even the $69 Chromecast Ultra requires a smart device to use.

Chromecast comes highly recommended if you’re a college student who is already using an Android device, but if you need a remote, you should look other places.

Chromecast vs Roku Photo by Roku

Roku $29.99 to $129

No company has invested more in ensuring that anyone, regardless of the TV they own, can have a smart TV than Roku. From the budget-priced Roku Express to the feature-packed Ultra HD monster known as the Roku Ultra, there’s a good reason why over 13 million people use Roku every month.

With an easy-to-understand remote and user interface, Roku is simple for children and adults alike to pick up and immediately start using. Each Roku device comes preloaded with standard streaming options like Netflix, Hulu, HBO Now, PlayStation Vue, and Amazon Prime—the same as those on the Chromecast—but that’s merely scratching the surface of what’s available channels. With over a 1,000 free and paid channel options, you’ll never run out of things to watch on Roku.


READ MORE:


Picking the model that’s right for you depends on your needs. If your TV still an A/V hookup, the $39.99 Roku Express+ has you covered, making it the only standalone streaming option available for converting old TVs into smart ones. Roku Streaming Stick serves up the height of power and portability, with a point anywhere remote that makes it ideal for taking on the road when you need entertainment in a hotel room. Of course, you can easily use any Roku with hotel Wi-Fi. Each model includes the ability to connect to Wi-Fi sources that require the user to log in.

Users with 4K television sets can get basic Ultra HD support with the $69.99 Roku Premiere or the $99 Premiere+, which adds advanced remote features like a headphone jack for private listening and Roku’s Night Viewing mode. Night Viewing automatically adjusts the sound of whatever you’re watching, so loud moments like explosions are softer and quiet moments like whispering are louder, letting you enjoy what you like to watch even if the rest of the house is sleeping.

If you don’t mind spending extra money for a premium experience, the Roku Ultra provides incredible Ultra HD streaming options, along with a remote that supports voice search for content and has a built-in speaker to help you locate it when you inevitably lose it under a sofa cushion. No matter what budget you are working with, Roku has you covered. It also works with Kodi, one of the most powerful media players on the market.

Roku vs Amazon Fire

Photo by Amazon

Amazon Fire $40 to $89.99

Amazon has invested heavily in its Fire TV line, including the Fire TV Stick. Each Fire TV comes with an Alexa voice remote that allows you to quickly pull up your favorite apps, play a song, or even order a pizza. For the $40 standard Amazon Fire Stick, that’s a lot of flexibility—especially when you consider the device is just $5 more than the remote-less Chromecast.

Each Amazon Fire streaming device provides access to over 140 apps and channels, including the same basics as Chromecast and Roku. With a DirecTV NOW subscription, you can watch live TV and sports, making this a strong contender for chordcutters. Amazon’s $40 Fire Stick supports 1080p HD video, while the $89.99 Fire TV option provides 4K Ultra HD video content.

Amazon Fire TV has a simple interface once you get used to it, but it can prove complicated at first. Alexia’s voice search helps ease the transition considerably, but if you’re trying to teach a technophobic parent how to use a streaming device, Roku can’t be beaten.

The Fire TV Stick is one of the best options available on the market today, thanks to its remote and ability to use third-party apps like Kodi. While it does not offer the same range of channel options as Roku, it gives you more content than you could ever consume. Keep in mind that using Amazon’s video series requires a $99-a-year Prime account, but you can access Netflix and other apps with your regular subscriptions. Clever users can also install Kodi on Amazon Fire.

Final verdict: Roku Stick

Roku streaming stick Photo by Roku

Based on price and the sheer number of options available, we recommend the Roku Stick as the go-to streaming device on the market. While Amazon Fire TV Stick has it beat by $10 and comes with an Alexa voice remote, Roku’s navigatable menus and broader selection of channels make it the obvious choice for new users. If you already have an Amazon Prime account, or you just need to have the Alexia voice remote, Amazon Fire Stick is a fantastic product and a close runner-up.

Even when taking into account the 4K market, Roku comes out on top thanks to the incredible $69.99 starting price for the Roku Premiere line. It’s worth splurging a bit to get the more powerful remote and the features that come with the $99.99 Roku Premiere+, but if you’re looking for 4K on a budget, simply no one does it better than Roku.

The Chromecast, while a fine device on its own, comes in last simply by nature of requiring you to have a smartphone to use. Children use streaming devices too, and you shouldn’t have to give a kid a smartphone to let them watch TV.

Debug
Why Roku is essential for cord-cutters
Before you head to the store, here's what you need to know about Roku.
From Our VICE Partners

Pure, uncut internet. Straight to your inbox.