‘Elisa & Marcela’ butchers a historic same-sex love story

Netflix

The hackneyed period drama is based on the story of Spain’s first recorded same-sex marriage.

Elisa & Marcela looks like the kind of movie you’re supposed to admire. The erotic drama—based on the true story of Spain’s first recorded same-sex wedding—features stunning black-and-white photography courtesy of director of photography Jennifer Cox. The camera lovingly lingers on a flower being doused with rain, holds carefully on church bells ringing, and bounces calmly on the ebb and flow of the ocean tide. Cox’s framing is often wide, emphasizing the space between the film’s protagonists and reinforcing the challenges they face. Unfortunately, the film’s visual mastery can’t make up for its lazy storytelling and groan-inducing attempts at intimacy.

Elisa & Marcela

 

RELEASE DATE: 6/7/2019
DIRECTOR: Isabel Coixet
STREAMING: Netflix
This period drama about the Spain’s first recorded same-sex marriage is all style, little substance.

The film begins in Argentina in the late 1800s and works its way through the Spanish-speaking world as it tells the story of two women who were married in 1901. Making the story even more remarkable is the fact that one woman, Elisa, had to disguise herself as a man named Mario Sánchez in order to trick the priest into marrying the couple. This story still resonates today, as many countries have not yet legalized gay marriage. It goes without saying that these women were heroes, but it’s hard to shake the feeling that we’ve seen this story told better elsewhere.

Elisa & Marcela shows plenty of promise at first. In addition to the thoughtful photography, Greta Fernández shines as Marcela, a bright-eyed teenager with an innocent urge to explore what the world has to offer. Natalia de Molina is less charming as Elisa, but she’s still intriguing as the older, mischievous, and slightly more worldly student who takes Marcela under her wing.

netflix elisa and marcela review Netflix

The two women fall in love almost immediately, and while the young actresses at the center of the film do their best to animate this love story with passion and curiosity, they just don’t get much to do. Five minutes into the film, they’re breathlessly in love; minutes later, the standard litany of obstacles—gossipy nuns, disapproving parents, draconian laws, and intolerant, brutish men—stands in the way of their romance. These adversaries lumber toward the protagonists, resulting in a two-hour film that feels like an eternity.

If you’ve seen a period piece about forbidden, same-sex romance—be it Brokeback Mountain, Carol, The Haindmaiden, or A Single Man—you will likely be able to predict every one of Elisa & Marcela’s hackneyed plot points long before they unfold. You’ll also wish you were celebrating Pride month by watching one of these much better films, or one of Netflix’s more effective original programs about the LGBTQIA community.

This isn’t to say Elisa & Marcela doesn’t have its moments of beauty. During their first romantic dalliance, the two strip down to their petticoats and frolic in the ocean. The scene is shot at a respectful distance, with the camera floating through the waves as the young women share a private moment, partially shielded from viewers. This kind of erotic restraint isn’t easy to pull off, and the scene once again demonstrates that the film’s visual style is much more sophisticated than its storytelling.

netflix elisa and marcela review Netflix/YouTube

Soon, though, the film is once again stymied by its flat script. “Boarding school or a convent, you decide,” Marcela’s abusive father says before literally dragging her through the mud, in a moment that will make even the biggest fans of maudlin period dramas roll their eyes.

You’ll root for the film to work until the two protagonists have their long-awaited sexual liaison around the halfway mark. Though the film presents Elisa and Marcela as repressed and unsure of their sexuality up to this point, the sex scene is overlong and aggressive, verging on softcore pornography. The couple’s cautious, charmingly awkward interactions get replaced by sucking toes, expert attention to each others’ nipples, and other moves that two young, virginal Catholic girls would be hard-pressed to acquire before the era of internet porn. (There’s one particularly ludicrous move involving an octopus, which you may want to add to your own arsenal if you’re kinky.)

There’s nothing wrong with an extended, steamy lesbian sex scene. Park Chan-wook’s The Handmaiden features one of the most explicit sequences this side of PornHub, but that scene manages the difficult balancing act of being sexy, beautifully shot, and appropriate to the story. Elisa & Marcela instead presents the manicured, toned bodies of its leads with a thoughtless, carnal gaze that arthouse cinema like this should have abandoned by now. Director Isabel Coixet’s artistic decisions are all style and no substance, and they’re proof that this story is in the wrong hands.

From here, the film is sunk. Fernández and de Molina lose the erotic hesitation that gave them something to cling to in the film’s first half. All that’s left for them is to struggle through the all-too-familiar beats of trying to maintain a forbidden love in a draconian world. Of course, the one man who feels any sympathy for them is in an interracial relationship, a revelation bound to induce one of many involuntary eye rolls througout the two-hour film.

If there’s one positive takeaway from Elisa and Marcela, it’s that in 2019, viewers can take their pick of far better films about the LGBTQIA experience, rather than settle for this uninspired romp.

Still not sure what to watch tonight? Here are our guides for the absolute best movies on Netflix, must-see Netflix original series, documentaries, docuseries, and movies.

Looking for something more specific? Here are our Netflix guides for the best war movies, documentaries, anime, indie flicks, true crime, food shows, rom-coms, LGBT movies, alien movies, gangster movies, Westerns, film noir, and movies based on true stories streaming right now. There are also sad movies guaranteed to make you cry, weird movies to melt your brain, old movies when you need something classic, and standup specials when you really need to laugh. Or check out Flixable, a search engine for Netflix.

Brenden Gallagher

Brenden Gallagher

Brenden Gallagher is a politics reporter and cultural commentator. His work has been published by Motherboard, Complex, and VH1. He’s the co-founder of Beer Money Films, an indie production company. Based in Los Angeles, he works in television drama as a writers assistant.