Photo via Key Foster/Flickr (CC BY 2.0) | Remix by Fernando Alfonso III

Net neutrality rules delayed by conservative FCC commissioners

Don't expect to see the rules for at least a few weeks.


Eric Geller


Published Feb 26, 2015   Updated May 29, 2021, 10:46 am CDT

As the FCC prepared to vote on strong net neutrality rules, conservatives, including the commission’s two Republican appointees, made no secret of their disdain for the FCC’s supposed lack of transparency.

Featured Video Hide

Despite the fact that independent regulatory agencies regularly withhold the details of proposed rules until they have been passed, conservatives made this secrecy a core part of their opposition to the net neutrality regulations.

Advertisement Hide

Conservative commissioners Ajit Pai and Michael O’Rielly both used their pre-vote speeches at Thursday’s open meeting to criticize the FCC for refusing to let the American people read the draft regulations prior to the vote. House Speaker John Boehner blasted the FCC for what he called a “total lack of transparency and accountability.”

“The text of the proposal is being kept hidden from the American people and their elected representatives in Congress,” Boehner said.

The document’s release, however, could hinge more on the conservative commissioners’ filing of their dissents than on the chairman’s reluctance to go public with the regulation.

Advertisement Hide

Before the rule can be released, FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler‘s staff must incorporate responses to the dissenting commissioners’ opinions into the discussion section of the document.

“What we have to address in the final order is their dissent,” FCC press secretary Kim Hart told the Daily Dot by phone.

“As is typical for a final rule and order, the final document is not available until staff makes final edits, which must be cleared by each commissioner,” Hart added in a statement.

Hart also estimated that this process could take several weeks.

After a commissioner has read his or her oral dissent at an open meeting, that commissioner has the option of amending the dissent for inclusion in the official record.

Advertisement Hide

“It is possible for a commissioner to have one transcribed statement from the meeting and attach another one to the item,” Hart told the Daily Dot.

Robin Colwell, chief of staff to Commissioner O’Rielly, told the Daily Dot that the commissioner would file a formal document sometime early next week, but dismissed the idea that the conservative commissioners could be blamed for a delay in the rule’s release.

“They have what we’ve given them,” Colwell said. “We’ll give them a longer version on Monday. This idea that we’re some sort of holdup in this process…they can put it out whenever they would like.”

The Daily Dot asked a spokesperson for Commissioner Pai if he had submitted his dissent. We will update if we hear back.

Update 2:54pm CT: Clarified the material that the chairman’s staff was waiting for and added FCC comments.

Advertisement Hide

Update 4:23pm CT: Added comments from Commissioner O’Rielly’s office.

H/T Motherboard | Photo via Key Foster/Flickr (CC BY 2.0) | Remix by Fernando Alfonso III

Share this article
*First Published: Feb 26, 2015, 4:31 pm CST