- Amanda Palmer dragged for ‘demanding’ coverage of her music Thursday 8:33 PM
- How to get free TikTok followers without downloading a virus Thursday 7:57 PM
- Trump Jr.s ‘Triggered’ topped best-seller’s list with help of RNC Thursday 7:41 PM
- FBI raided millionaire YouTuber’s home, allegedly took everything Thursday 6:55 PM
- A fake Labour party website is spreading disinformation in Britain Thursday 6:16 PM
- Twitter bans cricket club for posting ISIS content in apparent hack Thursday 6:12 PM
- This dad remade his daughter’s NSFW photo—and people are loving it Thursday 5:51 PM
- Teen allegedly posted ‘slave for sale’ Craigslist ad featuring his Black classmate Thursday 5:28 PM
- People are crushed that this teen love story might be a TikTok ‘joke’ Thursday 4:50 PM
- Is Jacob Wohl evading his Twitter ban with Jack Burkman’s account? Thursday 2:06 PM
- Biden’s most perplexing debate answers, explained Thursday 2:03 PM
- How to stream Colts vs. Texans on Thursday Night Football Thursday 12:52 PM
- Netflix drops ‘A Christmas Prince: The Royal Baby’ trailer Thursday 12:43 PM
- Uber says it will audio-record rides to address safety concerns Thursday 12:41 PM
- ‘Avengers: Endgame’ writers go in-depth on how they decided which superheroes lived and died Thursday 12:22 PM
After losing several of his jobs due to sexual abuse allegations last month, media personality Chris Hardwick has been reinstated as the host of AMC’s Talking Dead and Talking With Chris Hardwick. This move is already earning widespread criticism, as people express doubts about AMC’s investigation into Hardwick’s behavior.
When Hardwick’s ex-girlfriend Chloe Dykstra shared detailed accusations of domestic abuse in their relationship, she received overwhelming support from fans and public figures on social media. Hardwick, who denied the allegations, was quickly dropped from his TV talk shows and Comic-Con panels. Nerdist, the geek media outlet he co-founded in 2012, publicly severed ties. By reinstating him on Talking Dead and Talking With Chris Hardwick, AMC either implicitly denies the abuse allegations, or doesn’t see them as a problem.
AMC released this statement about Hardwick’s return:
“Following a comprehensive assessment by AMC, working with Ivy Kagan Bierman of the firm Loeb & Loeb, who has considerable experience in this area, Chris Hardwick will return to AMC as the host of Talking Dead and Talking With Chris Hardwick. We take these matters very seriously, and given the information available to us after a very careful review, including interviews with numerous individuals, we believe returning Chris to work is the appropriate step.”
Loeb & Loeb, the law firm conducting AMC’s assessment, also represents the Hearst family, Hardwick’s in-laws. Hardwick’s wife, heiress Lydia Hearst, and his mother-in-law, Patty Hearst, both publicly voiced support for Hardwick after the allegations came to light. It’s also worth noting that this wasn’t a criminal investigation. Rather than “proving” that Hardwick is innocent or the accusations were false, AMC’s assessment only means one thing: The network decided he was still worth employing as a TV host.
While Hardwick definitely has some supporters, the geek media community isn’t welcoming him back with open arms. On social media, the response to AMC’s decision is generally negative.
If only Chris Hardwick had some bad tweets. Then he definitely would’ve been fired https://t.co/4czmhgyk55— The Mary Sue (@TheMarySue) July 25, 2018
Time to BLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCK people standing up for Chris Hardwick.— Brandon Bird (@Brandon_Bird) July 25, 2018
Hardwick is returning to Talking Dead but only under these conditions:— Allie Goertz (@AllieGoertz) July 25, 2018
-He’s not go out at night.
-Not to have any close male friends unless they’re coworkers.
-Not to speak in public places.
-Not to take couple photos.
For the many people who believe Dykstra, Hardwick’s reinstatement proves that even in the #MeToo era, sexual abuse allegations are not enough to end a man’s career (or worse, that we’ve already hit Me Too “fatigue”). It also highlights the uneven nature of how media companies react to personal scandals.
In the past week, Disney fired Guardians of the Galaxy director James Gunn for making offensive jokes on Twitter—jokes that he posted several years ago, and only received attention thanks to “alt-right” trolls who objected to Gunn’s politics. Meanwhile, HBO confirmed it is “comfortable moving forward” with a second season of The Deuce, after its star James Franco was accused of sexual misconduct by five women in an L.A. Times exposé. At San Diego Comic-Con last weekend, Warner Bros. brought Johnny Depp onstage to promote Fantastic Beasts just an hour before his ex-wife Amber Heard (who accused him of domestic violence) appeared to promote Aquaman for the same studio.
These unequal responses suggest that Hollywood studios still don’t see sexual violence and domestic abuse as dealbreakers. At the same time, they often treat other types of public controversy more seriously.
Following the Harvey Weinstein scandal last year, reporters unearthed a shocking number of sexual abuse stories in Hollywood. However, Weinstein and Kevin Spacey—with dozens of allegations against them—are the only high-profile cases who faced career-ending consequences. Other celebrities either faced reputational damage while continuing to get work (Depp, Franco, T.J. Miller, Joss Whedon), or lost their jobs before gearing up for a comeback (Hardwick, Louis C.K., Jeffrey Tambor). This creates the impression that either all these women are lying (which is not the case), or that their trauma is less important than a famous abuser’s career.
Gavia Baker-Whitelaw is a staff writer at the Daily Dot, covering geek culture and fandom. Specializing in sci-fi movies and superheroes, she also appears as a film and TV critic on BBC radio. Elsewhere, she co-hosts the pop culture podcast Overinvested. Follow her on Twitter: @Hello_Tailor