What if geek girls acted like geek guys?

The concept of fake geek girls is now so widespread that the joke needs no explanation.


Gavia Baker-Whitelaw

Internet Culture

Published Aug 27, 2014   Updated May 30, 2021, 5:06 pm CDT

Imagine a world in which certain people couldn’t go into a comic book store without being mocked and derided due to their gender. A truly ridiculous scenario, we can all agree.

The new BuzzFeed video “If Geek Girls Acted Like Geek Guys”—starring former Daily Dot writer Gaby Dunn—obviously riffs on the idea of fake geek girls, with the gender roles reversed. Instead of a geek guy demanding to see a girl’s nerd credentials, we see a female comic store employee asking if a guy is into comics because of his mom or girlfriend, and making weird comments about whether he cosplays “slutty Thor.”

This is one of those satirical videos that proves its point in the comments section. Just within the top page of YouTube comments we already have such gems as “Feminazi” (a fine vintage of YouTube criticism, repeated by several people), and someone pondering, “Does a hot girl that’s into games and anime really get that annoyed about being hit on?” In response to that last question, this video indicates that the answer is yes.

This video is oddly encouraging, in a way. The concept of fake geek girls is now so widespread that the joke needs no explanation: Either you recognize the ridiculousness of this kind of geek culture gatekeeping, or you’re someone who unironically uses the word “feminazi” in a YouTube comment. In that context, it’s pretty clear which side you should be aiming for. 

Screengrab via BuzzFeed Yellow/YouTube

Share this article
*First Published: Aug 27, 2014, 9:07 am CDT