There are so many great podcasts now that it’s hard to keep track. Welcome to Night Vale and The Thrilling Adventure Hour are the obvious choices if you have any interest in audio fiction, but it’s a little harder to pick out the best fandom talk shows and geeky discussion podcasts. That’s why we’ve been taking a careful look at what’s on offer, and have whittled the many options down to a streamlined list of 11.
Some of these are fandom-specific (very specific, in the case of cartoon Batman psychoanalysis podcast The Arkham Sessions) while others are more general, but all of them are definitely worth a listen.
1) The Baker Street Babes
Sherlock Holmes fandom is intimidatingly huge, and intimidatingly long-lived. So, the enduring popularity of the Baker Street Babes should prove their quality as Sherlock Holmes commentators.
Their podcasts cover everything from decades-old fandom discussions to Sherlock TV fan events, and have developed a dedicated following of their own. They’ve even published a book: The One Fixed Point In A Changing Age: Essays on Sherlockiana By Online Fandom.
2) Rocket Talk
Tor.com’s in-house podcast is dedicated to conversations about science fiction and the sci-fi/fantasy community, and often brings in well-known authors as guest hosts. This show doesn’t require you to be a regular listener, because some weeks the episode will be dedicated to an audio reading of short fiction, while the next week is a discussion of something like The LEGO Movie, the Hugo Awards, or superhero TV shows.
3) Rachel and Miles X-Plain the X-Men
The title says it all, really. Longtime comic book fans Rachel and Miles discuss the delightfully convoluted history of the X-Men, in a way that is equally interesting for experts and total newbies alike. We interviewed them last year when X-Plain the X-Men was just starting to take off, and since then they’ve gone semi-pro through Patreon and merchandising.
4) The Nerdist Podcast
This is the biggest podcast on the list, attracting celebrities like Joss Whedon, Benedict Cumberbatch, Gillian Anderson, and William Shatner, along with well-known screenwriters, comedians, and comic book creators. The format is like a casual talk show hosted by the Nerdist’s Chris Hardwick, and episodes can often be more than an hour long.
There are plenty of hidden gems in the Nerdist’s lengthy back-catalogue, such as the episode where Charlie Hunnam (Pacific Rim) talks about his obsession with writing a historical film about Vlad the Impaler, or the one where Tom Cruise narrates an impromptu autobiography and repeatedly assures us that he “loves movies” in increasingly over-enthusiastic tones. Check the episode list for your favorite geek-culture celebrities; the resulting interview is certain to be far more satisfying than your average YouTube soundbite or magazine article.
5) Fangirl Happy Hour
This one only started a few weeks ago, but it’s a must-listen if you’re in need of reliable media recommendations. Co-hosted by Renay from Ladybusiness and Ana from the hugely popular Book Smugglers book review blog, this podcast combines fandom-related debate/criticism with a whole slew of recommendations for upcoming TV shows, comics, books, and movies. Fangirl Happy Hour is especially good if you’re looking for books and movies with diverse protagonists or creators.