Nintendo removes user-built trans flag from 'Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.'


Super Smash Bros. Ultimate player’s trans flag removed for being ‘political’

'Not surprising, but awful.'


Kris Seavers


Posted on Apr 22, 2019   Updated on May 20, 2021, 2:13 pm CDT

A trans gamer is looking for answers from Nintendo after an in-game transgender flag she made was removed from Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, apparently because the flag was deemed to be “harmful” and “political.”

The new custom stage-building feature in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate initially caused controversy when gamers flooded the game with penis drawings. Players seemed hellbent on proving that the game’s shape-detection software would not flag every phallic rendering. While many of the penis drawings were eventually taken down, screenshots indicate Smash Bros. was overrun with crude images.

But Twitter user @WarmSafflina, who goes by Rose, had a different approach to the freedom of building her own stage in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. Rose built a stage that clearly represented the transgender flag—and was shocked to find it later taken down.

In a detailed Twitter thread, first reported by the Mary Sue, Rose explained her confusion after her trans flag drawing was removed from the game and her account was suspended for nine hours.

Rose soon contacted Nintendo customer service to understand why the action had been taken. She told the Daily Dot that, through a series of conversations with customer service representatives, she learned her trans flag stage had been reported by other users and marked “political.” According to Rose, a customer service supervisor also told her they, personally, are a “trans ally” but could not do much more than speculate why her flag had been removed.

“The best they could offer is because [the trans flag] was political and that they had deleted other (unspecified) flags,” Rose said. “They did reassure me once again that they didn’t share that view and promised to pass it along up the chain of command for further review.”

A screenshot Rose shared on Twitter showed the initial notice she received about the removal of her trans flag. The violation was cited as “inappropriate and/or harmful.” As Rose pointed out, statements of “political” nature are not banned in Nintendo’s Code of Conduct, so it’s unclear what Nintendo considers a “political” statement, much less a “harmful” one.

Nintendo did not immediately respond to the Daily Dot’s request for comment. Meanwhile, because of her Twitter thread, Rose said she’s facing an onslaught of transphobic remarks.

“It’s been awful,” Rose said. “Not surprising, but awful. I’ve been misgendered, called a ‘tranny,’ accused of hawking an ideology that pushes mutilation on children. The accusations that involve children sting the most. It’s the children who need the support more than anyone.”

Rose said if Nintendo continues taking action against her for posting trans-inclusive content, she’ll consider legal options. But she’s hoping it doesn’t come to that.

“Going forward I hope Nintendo will come out and say they don’t have a policy against trans-inclusive content,” Rose said. “And I will be satisfied with that answer so long they stop removing stages for trans-inclusive content and also remove the strike from my account.”


H/T the Mary Sue

Share this article
*First Published: Apr 22, 2019, 7:37 pm CDT