- White woman demanding strangers ‘repent’ for Christ sparks conversation on mental illness and racism Sunday 9:27 PM
- Amtrak employee asked a NAACP lawyer to move from her train seat Sunday 7:54 PM
- Billie Eilish fans riot after being referred to as ‘Avocados’ Sunday 4:37 PM
- Beyhive coming for Sainsbury’s supermarket over Ivy Park shade Sunday 3:17 PM
- Antique store blasted for selling ‘white only’ signs Sunday 1:45 PM
- DaBaby explains altercation with hotel employee after video goes viral Sunday 12:32 PM
- Kanye faces backlash for headlining Christian event with anti-LGBTQ leaders Sunday 10:31 AM
- Why is Yennefer of Vengerberg so different in Netflix’s ‘The Witcher’? Sunday 10:00 AM
- Actress slammed for ‘acid attack-face’ TikTok challenge Sunday 9:46 AM
- ‘Weathering With You’ blends fantasy and realism in a magical love story Saturday 6:18 PM
- Kidnapped teen used Snapchat to get rescued Saturday 4:35 PM
- What fans do and don’t want to see in future ‘Far Cry’ installments Saturday 4:26 PM
- Aaron Carter accused of stealing lion art for merch Saturday 3:10 PM
- Instagram’s hidden like counts were inspired by a ‘Black Mirror’ episode Saturday 2:06 PM
- Student says they were expelled for tricking teacher into making inappropriate TikTok Saturday 12:26 PM
Anti-abortion advocates are sharing a video of unclear origins on Twitter that shows people in lab coats toying with what people claim to be aborted fetuses. But a look at the pixelated, low-quality video shows the small figures are most likely dolls that are used in medical practices. Still, that hasn’t stopped people—mostly men—from using the video to try and spread panic.
“This my friends is what EVIL looks like!” tweeted Rev. Frank Pavone, who runs an anti-abortion ministry called Priests for Life. “Our own investigation into the abortion industry saw them playing catch with the babies in the hallway. Another investigation saw them playing ‘wishbone’ with the aborted baby body parts.”
The six-second clip shows two people wearing white lab coats and gloves in what appears to be a medical or educational facility. There is no visible blood or bodily fluid as they bounce what look like rubber dolls or figures on a metal tray.
It’s not the first time the video has floated online. It appeared in a July 2018 article on anti-abortion news website LifeNew.com, which has reported false information in the past. The LifeNews article claims the video was found on a Venezuelan Facebook account called “Vídeos Mundo Curioso,” which no longer exists. Cheryl Sullenger, who authored the LifeNews article and is the senior vice president for anti-abortion organization Operation Rescue, did not respond to the Daily Dot’s request for comment.
One day after the LifeNews post, far-right website Big League Politics reported on the clip, which had at one point been uploaded to YouTube. The video has now “been removed for violating YouTube’s policy on violent or graphic content,” but it’s unclear how YouTube determined the video was graphic. YouTube did not immediately respond to the Daily Dot’s request for comment.
Pavone also did not respond to the Daily Dot’s request for comment. Twitter user @_thomicastillo, who lives in Argentina and was among the first to recirculate the video this week, told the Daily Dot in Spanish that he didn’t know where the video originated but that he thought it was real.
After being circulated this week via multiple accounts, the video is causing mass outrage. It’s been shared by Republican conspiracy theorists like Jack Posobiec, who has been retweeted by President Donald Trump, and pundit Matt Walsh, who compared abortion providers to ISIS.
Dr. Jennifer Gunter is an OB-GYN who is active on Twitter and often busts myths about abortion and other medical misconceptions. She told the Daily Dot that she had only seen the clip on her phone and that it’s difficult to say for sure what the people in the video are handling. Still, she said it’s unlikely the video shows medical professionals handling a fetus after an abortion.
“I can’t tell if they are old specimens, dolls, bodies on the morgue,” Gunter said. “I don’t think people would be dressed like that and handling dolls. We also don’t know if they are fetuses, premature neonates who died, or if they are nonhuman primates! However, nothing about the video says to me this was immediately after an abortion.”
When someone on Twitter tried to suggest they were neonatal dolls, Walsh, whose bio doesn’t reflect any experience in the medical field, argued with them, claiming this is the result of a “dilation and extraction” method. It wasn’t clear how he arrived at that conclusion. He called it “partial-birth abortion” too, which is not a medical term, it’s a political one, according to NPR. The term was developed specifically to raise public opposition against abortion.
There are people arguing the invalidity of the video, but they are in the minority in large part because of where the video is being tweeted from: anti-abortion circles.
It’s the use of fake videos to rile up the gullible that I find infuriating. This, and the fact they strongly imply that doctors who perform abortions are taking this as a joke.— mindfulhealthiskey (@mindfulhealth1) June 6, 2019
Why would you perpetuate this. It’s clearly fake. This is a perfect example for why I left the NRA. Good God man. Hope you got the clicks you were looking for.— Andy Sigler (@Andyinthe901) June 5, 2019
Many people on Twitter insisted the “fetuses” involved in the video look unrealistic and that the context of the video doesn’t imply that it shows a post-operation setting.
Massive prize for whoever managed to dry out these clearly real fetuses so they don’t even make gloves or trays wet. We def need more women’s representation in the fake abortion video production sector— silentsanta (@silentsantaNZ) June 6, 2019
I knew Matt wasn't the sharpest pencil in the box but Jesus Christ.— Palle (@Palle_Hoffstein) June 6, 2019
I am still leaning towards thinking they are toys, but only because they look way too clean— Hello there (@2much2todo) June 6, 2019
Twitter has an extensive set of rules against videos that are violent and “gory,” plus rules against spamming, but the policy strictly on fake information is not clear, aside from a 2017 blog post that states the site is working to improve this. This is not the first time such content has been allowed to remain on such platforms; recently, Facebook refused to remove a doctored video showing House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.).
A Twitter representative said they’re looking into the abortion doll video, and the Daily Dot will update the report when they respond.
- Women’s stories about breast lumps highlight American healthcare failure
- Miley Cyrus accused of copying Instagram artist’s sensual fruit art
- YouTube’s algorithm is reportedly helping pedophiles find home videos of kids
Got five minutes? We’d love to hear from you. Help shape our journalism and be entered to win an Amazon gift card by filling out our 2019 reader survey.
Samira Sadeque is a New York-based journalist reporting on immigration, sexual violence, and mental health, and will sometimes write about memes and dinosaurs too. Her work also appears in Reuters, NPR, and NBC among other publications. She graduated from Columbia Journalism School, and her work has been nominated for SAJA awards. Follow: @Samideque