- ‘The Mandalorian’ comes to a crossroads in Chapter 3 4 Years Ago
- Apple TV’s ‘Servant’ will make you scared of reborn dolls 4 Years Ago
- Lindsey Graham roasted for turning his back on a veteran 4 Years Ago
- Scooter Braun asks Taylor Swift for ‘resolution’ after allegedly getting death threats 4 Years Ago
- ‘Frozen 2’ plays it safe and lacks the magic of the original 4 Years Ago
- Graphic video shows police pinning man face-down in subway station 4 Years Ago
- Mini-documentary shows Trump supporters clashing at Denny’s Today 11:52 AM
- Here’s why ‘Furry and Proud’ is trending on Twitter Today 11:16 AM
- Sacha Baron Cohen calls tech giants the ‘greatest propaganda machine in history’ Today 11:04 AM
- ‘Resistance Reborn’ is a must-read before ‘The Rise of Skywalker’ Today 10:14 AM
- Stephen Miller should be fired, more than 100 lawmakers say Today 9:56 AM
- YouTube star Bretman Rock goes off on fans who wanted selfies during his dad’s funeral Today 9:14 AM
- The U.S. Army is reevaluating its use of TikTok after security concerns Today 8:45 AM
- Nurse’s TikTok video accused of being insensitive to patient trauma Today 8:16 AM
- The tweet showing a man talking to a woman in a club is gone but not forgotten Today 8:00 AM
Why users are waging war against Instagram’s confusing policies on nude selfies
Chrissy Teigen is just the latest celebrity to protest the site’s moderation guidelines.
The boundary between art, casual photos, and porn can sometimes feel difficult to determine, and sometimes images span multiple or all three of these categories. Found object art can turn the vacation photos that litter Instagram into artistic expression, while some porn is explicitly shot with aesthetics in mind, creating works of art that are both beautiful and sensual.
Instagram user Hazel (@ropehaze), for example, produces images that are visually stunning, but also reflective of her role in the BDSM community. Art? Porn? Commemorations of BDSM events? All of the above?
Documentary photographer Leah Millis (@leahmillis) covers topics like culture and the drought for the San Francisco Chronicle, but on her Instagram account, she gives her followers a more personal view of life.
A photo posted by Leah Millis (@leahmillis) on
Tom Anderson (@myspacetom)—yes, that Tom—takes followers on his around the world adventures.
A photo posted by Tom Anderson (@myspacetom) on
Many of the accounts profiled in Instagram’s user features are artists, illustrators, and photographers, but at the same time it advocates for art, Instagram continues to curtail creativity with a zero tolerance policy not just for nipples, but for nudes, according to the user guidelines.
“We know that there are times when people might want to share nude images that are artistic or creative in nature, but for a variety of reasons, we don’t allow nudity on Instagram,” the site guidelines state. Many users get around this restriction by posting images suggestive of nudity in which models are at least partially clothed, as in the case of these images from Kim Kardashian, photographer Jess Ewald, Victoria’s Secret model Candice Swanepoel, and Nicki Minaj.
A photo posted by Nicki Minaj (@nickiminaj) on
Such images aren’t just about the nudity of the model, but the form and composition of the image; the models themselves are beautiful, but the photographs are carefully and thoughtfully constructed. They are, in other words, works of art. They also technically pass Instagram standards, given costuming and composition.
Other photographs, though, clearly break the rules, like this pregnancy announcement from model Doutzen Kroes:
A photo posted by Doutzen Kroes (@doutzen) on
Similarly, photographer David Alan Harvey skirts the guidelines with this image suggestive of nudity, although the framing makes it difficult to ascertain precisely what the subjects are(n’t?) wearing.
Rio de Janeiro. The gay gala camarote at the Candybox in the Sambodromo Carnaval parade ground. Super good vibes all around. Stay tuned for my upcoming BeachGames zine. A real life story.#rio #beachgames
A photo posted by David Alan Harvey (@davidalanharvey) on
When it comes to the selective enforcement of Instagram’s ban on nude and suggestive images, a number of issues become readily apparent. Despite the site’s claim that even artistic nudes aren’t allowed, it often gives certain photos a pass, even though they’re on high-profile accounts that administrators are no doubt aware of and have sometimes even featured. It’s clear that administrators consider such pictures to be art photography, and they have little interest in taking them down.
The site also tends to view nudes or partial nudes more favorably when they involve conventionally attractive female subjects. Fat women like Samm Newman, for example, report that their accounts have been deleted after uploading photos in their underwear—which don’t violate the guidelines—suggesting a fatphobic streak among moderators. Transgender users are also more prone to photo deletion and account suspension.
The divides in terms of what Instagram finds acceptable for user expression are troubling, as the site can’t seem to make up its mind when it comes to evaluating images and accounts.
It’s a private service and photographers have access to other venues for distributing their work. If artistic nudes aren’t allowed, as stated under the policy, then they should be removed, allowing photographers to take their work elsewhere, to a platform that doesn’t threaten them with the risk of losing their content. If they are permitted, the policy needs to be revised to reflect this.
As the operator of a service in an era concerned with issues like revenge porn and nude photographs of underage people, along with the accompanying liability, Instagram is within its rights to set out a user policy regarding nudes and near-nudes. The issue is the inconsistent application of that policy, which constantly leaves users guessing when it comes to uploading photographs as they attempt to gauge whether those images are likely to face deletion.
Curiously, nudity in photographs of paintings, statues, and other works of art is acceptable. The fact that this is specifically discussed in the user policy is a subtle acknowledgement of the fact that the naked body has been a part of art and culture for thousands of years. Sadly, a service allegedly dedicated to artistic expression doesn’t support the same free expression for its members.
S.E. Smith is a writer, editor, and agitator with regular appearances in the Guardian, AlterNet, and Salon, along with several anthologies. Smith also serves as the Social Justice Editor for xoJane and will be co-chairing Wiscon 40—the preeminent feminist science-fiction conference—in 2016.
Photo via SeanJCPhoto/Flickr (CC BY 2.0)
s.e. smith is a Northern California-based journalist and writer focusing on social justice issues. smith's work has appeared in publications like Esquire, the Guardian, Rolling Stone, In These Times, Bitch Magazine, and Pacific Standard.