Illustration by Max Fleishman

Heinz bottle offers recipe for ‘ketchup cake’—and some maniac actually made it

Wonders never cease.

Feb 29, 2020, 1:14 am*

Internet Culture

Ketchup is a condiment used to spruce up many a dish. It makes fries taste better. 

It’s perfect on hamburgers. 

It’s good on a hot dog, even if haters don’t agree. 

When it’s far away from pastries and other baked goods, ketchup is a delightful treat. You know what else is a delightful treat? Cake.

It’s great for parties.

It’s perfect for when you’re hungover and want something sweet. 

It’s a nice post-workout snack.

When cake and ketchup are at least 1,000 miles apart, all is good in the world. So who in their right mind thought it was a good idea to bake a ketchup cake? Someone from Reddit is the answer. User Big_Black_Cat was the one to notice that the back of his Canadian Heinz ketchup bottle offered a recipe for such an abomination.

View post on

Then, against all common sense, gregnuttle decided to actually bake it, chronicling his culinary adventure on YouTube and Imgur.

Ketchup Cake Batter

View post on

Ketchup Cake

No one was more confused about this than other redditors. And rightfully so. A ketchup cake is a crime against humanity, and hundred of people had strong opinions about this stomach-churning cake suggestion that no one asked for. 


This comment set the tone for what would become a thread of shock and confectionery outrage. 


After gregnuttle finished cooking the ketchup cake, he uploaded a video of his dog eating it. 

Canine abuse at its finest.


Agreed. Just hearing the words “ketchup cake” would induce nausea in any young child.


This is not OK. 


Everything makes sense now. This is all Canada’s fault. 

So there you have it. A recipe for a ketchup cake exists in the world, and people are actually making it. How could Heinz Canada do this? After all the talk of free healthcare, cheap living, and Canadian niceness, you decide to mix ketchup with cake. If Trump wins the presidency, there’s going to be millions of Americans with nowhere to go. 

Share this article
*First Published: Aug 25, 2016, 3:05 pm