- This ‘Little Women’ scene just became a meme Monday 7:03 PM
- Playable version of Blizzard’s ‘StarCraft: Ghost’ leaks online nearly 15 years after cancelation Monday 6:31 PM
- This Twitter extension can block unsolicited nudes from your inbox Monday 6:01 PM
- Jeffree Star wears cornrows after being accused of cultural appropriation Monday 4:49 PM
- Jeff Bezos says he’ll commit $10 billion to combat climate change Monday 4:18 PM
- A TikTok user went on a mission to turn his urine blue by chugging food coloring Monday 3:55 PM
- YouTuber’s vacation in ‘Bali’ was actually staged at Ikea Monday 3:14 PM
- Video shows liquor store manager calling employee ‘f*cking worthless’ Monday 1:16 PM
- Instagram influencer scams followers out of $1.5 million Monday 12:22 PM
- Why did the Israeli military tweet this thirst trap? Monday 10:43 AM
- Jake Paul wants you to have financial freedom… by paying him a monthly fee Monday 10:40 AM
- Tweets from Sanders supporters are terrifying the establishment Monday 10:15 AM
- Zuckerberg says he supports 1 bill in Congress that would regulate Facebook Monday 10:11 AM
- Uncanny ‘Back to the Future’ deepfake transports Tom Holland and Robert Downey, Jr. to 1985 Monday 10:04 AM
- Everyone is doing the Renegade. Including the teen who started it Monday 9:23 AM
The Rosetta probe’s latest discovery has sparked a massive mystery
It’s water, but not as we know it.
The Rosetta probe that landed on a comet in November has discovered water and opened the door to an entirely new mystery.
The European Space Agency announced on Wednesday that the probe, which is sitting on Comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, had detected water vapor emanating from the flying space rock. What scientists didn’t expect, however, was for the water to be of a starkly different form than the water with which humans interact every day.
Rosetta measured the ratio of two elements, deuterium and hydrogen, in the comet’s water.
“The key to determining where [Earth’s] water originated is in its ‘flavour,'” the ESA said in its statement, “in this case the proportion of deuterium—a form of hydrogen with an additional neutron—to normal hydrogen.”
The “D/H ratio” for Comet 67P suggests that the water inside has three times more deuterium than water on our planet.
This finding is significant because it raises questions about a major scientific theory: that the water currently on Earth came from comets and asteroids hitting the planet and depositing their water on its surface.
The origins of the Earth’s water are closely studied, because the arrival of this water—which likely followed the Earth’s initial supply boiling off during the planet’s extremely hot formation—was the crucial factor that supported the formation of life.
The ESA chart below illustrates how different our water’s D/H ratio is from that of Comet 67P’s water.
Comet 67P is considered a Jupiter-family comet because its orbit takes it just beyond Jupiter at its farthest point from the sun. The new finding suggests that scientists have much to learn about the origins of both the Jupiter-family comets and Earth’s water.
“Our finding also rules out the idea that Jupiter-family comets contain solely Earth ocean-like water, and adds weight to models that place more emphasis on asteroids as the main delivery mechanism for Earth’s oceans,” said ESA researcher Kathrin Altwegg, who supervises the use of the Rosetta Orbiter Spectrometer for Ion and Neutral Analysis (ROSINA) apparatus.
Altwegg and her team published their complete findings in the journal Science.
In October 2011, the ESA’s Herschel observatory used its infrared instruments to detect a D/H ratio on Comet 103P/Hartley 2, another Jupiter-family comet, that was almost identical to that of Earth. Hartley 2 was dubbed “the first comet containing water that is similar in isotopic composition to that in Earth’s oceans.”
For the ESA, Herschel’s finding suggested “contrary to earlier belief, comets may well have played an important role in bringing water to our planet.” Now the agency has contrary data from another Jupiter-family comet.
The mystery of Earth’s water continues.
Photo via European Space Agency/Flickr (CC BY SA 2.0)
Eric Geller is a politics reporter who focuses on cybersecurity, surveillance, encryption, and privacy. A former staff writer at the Daily Dot, Geller joined Politico in June 2016, where he's focused on policymaking at the White House, the Justice Department, the State Department, and the Commerce Department.