- Disabled people with service dogs say Uber, Lyft drivers are denying them rides 6 Years Ago
- TikTok teen famous for greasy hair ends her 8-year reign 6 Years Ago
- Police handcuff brown man at subway station for carrying a toy gun Today 1:20 PM
- Fake clip of Sanders quoting infamous ‘hot chip’ tweet is duping people online Today 1:16 PM
- The Mars Volta’s Cedric Bixler-Zavala alleges Scientologists behind dog’s death Today 12:46 PM
- Eminem responds to critics: ‘This album was not made for the squeamish’ Today 12:42 PM
- ‘The poet, the poem’ meme takes iconic lines and turns them into art Today 12:40 PM
- People are making dark memes about the coronavirus Today 12:27 PM
- Trump camp’s ‘head on a pike’ impeachment threat hit with memes Today 11:34 AM
- What is the #FreeBritney movement, and why is Cher tweeting about it? Today 10:52 AM
- This YouTuber claims the Saudi government plotted to kidnap him on U.S. soil Today 10:30 AM
- Report: Jack Dorsey declined to host a fundraiser for Tulsi Gabbard Today 10:22 AM
- Bernie Sanders plugs Joe Rogan endorsement—and women are furious Today 10:04 AM
- Young woman using TikTok to document the end of her life says she’s dying next week Today 8:43 AM
- London’s real-time facial recognition program a ‘breathtaking assault’ on civil rights Today 8:23 AM
Yelp reviewers’ scathing criticisms outed by Virginia court
Your negative Yelp reviews might not be as safe as you thought.
Yelp reviewers have a certain level of anonymity that allows them to, ideally, be honest about the businesses they’re reviewing.
This week, the Virginia Court of Appeals ruled that the identities of seven Yelp reviewers who trashed a carpet cleaning business online must be handed over by Yelp because the owner of the business said the users violated Yelp’s terms of service.
Joe Hadeed of Virginia’s Hadeed Carpeting Cleaning had his attorney issue a subpoena to Yelp requesting the names of the seven offending reviewers, and an Alexandria court ruled that Yelp has to comply. Because the reviewers were not actual customers and thus may have broken Yelp’s rules for reviewing they were not protected by First Amendment rights.
According to the Washington Times, Hadeed had to prove there was a strong case for a lawsuit against these seven people, and since he did, the court ruled he was to be privy to their information. Hadeed told the court he believed the reviews, which focused on false advertising and unethical business practices, were being submitted multiple times under different names by the same people. The court said that First Amendment rights do not cover deliberately false statements and agreed that Mr. Hadeed “provided sufficient reason to think the users might not have been customers.” The reviews did not match actual customers kept in the company’s database.
Yelp has said that all the accounts have different IP addresses. The company’s lawyers said there were protections against identifying people who make anonymous comments online, but the court ruled the comments were “potentially libelous.”
“We are disappointed that the Virginia Court of Appeals has issued a ruling that fails to adequately protect free speech rights on the internet, and which allows businesses to seek personal details about website users — without any evidence of wrongdoing — in efforts to silence online critics,” Yelp spokesman Vince Sollitto said in a statement to the Washington Times.
However, the court ruled the same protections can not be applied to false statements online.
Gaby Dunn is an actress, comedian, and blogger who covered YouTube for the Daily Dot. Since 2016, she’s hosted the podcast ‘Bad with Money,’ and operates a successful YouTube channel. Her writing has appeared in the New York Times, the Boston Globe, Vice, and Salon.