Texas Gov. Greg Abbott. He signed a law targeting social media companies.

Gage Skidmore/Flickr (CC-BY-SA)

‘Unconstitutional and dangerous’: New Texas social media law immediately criticized

The law is already being called 'unconstitutional and dangerous.'


Andrew Wyrich


Posted on Sep 10, 2021   Updated on Sep 10, 2021, 12:55 pm CDT

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) signed a controversial law on Thursday that prohibits big tech companies from banning or blocking users based on the “viewpoint of the user.”

The law, HB 20, is almost certain to face legal challenges like a similar law that was passed in Florida did earlier this year. The Florida law was signed, faced a lawsuit, and was subsequently blocked by a federal judge.

Specifically, the Texas law would not allow a social media platform like Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube to “censor a user, a user’s expression, or a user’s ability to receive the expression of another person” based on a person’s “viewpoint.” The law would also allow for private citizens and the Texas attorney general to sue social media companies for violating the law.

The law was created in response to claims by Republicans that social media sites are suppressing conservatives online, a claim that lacks significant evidence.

Abbott, in a statement released after signing the law, alluded to those claims.

“Social media websites have become our modern-day public square. They are a place for healthy public debate where information should be able to flow freely—but there is a dangerous movement by social media companies to silence conservative viewpoints and ideas. That is wrong, and we will not allow it in Texas,” Abbott said.

Much like the social media law in Florida, the Texas law faced immediate pushback, specifically claims that it violates the First Amendment rights of social media companies to moderate content.

NetChoice, a tech lobby group that was was part of an effort to sue Florida’s law, called the Texas law “unconstitutional and dangerous.”

“By empowering the government to control online speech, HB 20 clearly violates the First Amendment,” Steve DelBianco, president of NetChoice, said in a statement. “This law essentially creates a new Fairness Doctrine for the internet which will only make it harder for conservatives to share their news and views online.”

DelBianco continued: “HB 20 has the same First Amendment flaws as the Florida law that a federal court blocked this summer. The same outcome will almost certainly occur in Texas.”

Meanwhile, Eric Goldman, a professor at Santa Clara University School of Law, told the Washington Post that the new law in Texas doesn’t “survive critical scrutiny.” He added that both Texas and Florida’s laws “represent an effort to play for partisan crown, not to make good policy.”

Read more about Big Tech

Congress barrels forward with EARN IT Act, determined to end encrypted messaging online
How little tech is turning the tide in the fight against big tech
FTC warns of ‘huge surge’ in social media scams
How the FTC can use ‘data minimization’ to immediately strengthen consumer privacy
Sign up to receive the Daily Dot’s Internet Insider newsletter for urgent news from the frontline of online.
Share this article
*First Published: Sep 10, 2021, 9:17 am CDT