- Hacker infiltrates Nest cameras to gain PewDiePie subscribers 3 Years Ago
- YouTube time traveler claims MLK’s granddaughter will be the last U.S. president Today 2:30 PM
- Media coverage of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Twitch cameo erases Chelsea Manning Today 1:39 PM
- New Alexa skill lets you sing with Queen’s Freddie Mercury Today 1:13 PM
- Netflix is the first streaming platform to join MPAA Today 12:59 PM
- Can you spot an email from a hacker? Today 12:46 PM
- Gina Rodriguez cries over being called anti-Black, gets dragged for ‘fake tears’ Today 12:21 PM
- Boots Riley explains why he got snubbed by the Oscars Today 12:20 PM
- Review: ‘Buffy’ returns with a modern comic book reboot Today 11:47 AM
- You’re about to see a lot more Netflix on your Instagram Today 11:32 AM
- Covington students defend blackface video as ‘school spirit’ Today 11:30 AM
- This YouTuber reportedly filmed himself abusing his cat—and his channel is still active Today 11:18 AM
- Dodie Clark hid a secret song in her videos Today 11:08 AM
- YouTube TV is finally available in your city Today 11:03 AM
- Ivanka Trump gears up for 2020 by following her dad’s opponents on Twitter Today 10:21 AM
Controversy is brewing around ‘Underground Airlines,’ a new novel that mixes slavery and sci-fi
‘Underground Airlines’ is about a former slave turned slave-catching bounty hunter.
When the New York Times published an interview promoting a novel that “dares to mix slavery and sci-fi,” the reactions from literary circles on Twitter were swift and damning. Was it really fair for a white author to be praised as “fearless” for writing a book like this one?
Underground Airlines is a new thriller by novelist and playwright Ben H. Winters, set in an alternate reality where the American Civil War never happened. The protagonist is a former slave who nows works as a bounty hunter, specializing in tracking down escaped slaves. After capturing more than 200 people, Victor’s next task is to infiltrate an abolitionist movement known as the Underground Airlines.
In the interview, Winters is forthright about the controversial nature of this subject-matter. “The first impulse is to go, oh man, are you supposed to be writing about that, as a white American?” he told the Times. “We tend to think of racism and slavery as something that’s appropriate only for black artists to engage with, and there’s something troubling and perverse about that.”
Other authors did not accept this attitude with open arms.
Who knows, the book could be great, but it’s beyond tiresome to see this kind of writing be praised as original and “fearless.” It’s not.
— Malinda Lo (@malindalo) July 5, 2016
“Someone should write a sci-fi novel tackling American slavery and black racial identity. It should be ME.”
-White dudes everywhere.
— J. Ire (@justinaireland) July 5, 2016
An established author telling stories of PoC, risks nothing. Absolutely nothing. The most they’ll suffer is some side eye and snarky tweets.
— J. Ire (@justinaireland) July 5, 2016
The book was published this week and has already landed a TV deal, with Winters writing the pilot script.
Some found this positive coverage galling for a number of reasons. First of all, it’s demonstrably harder for authors of color to receive equal media attention alongside white writers. Secondly, the Times story plays into a long tradition of white artists being celebrated for tackling topics others have already covered with more personal expertise.
Underground Airlines is especially frustrating for fans of the acclaimed sci-fi author Octavia Butler, whose work often explored racist and sexist power structures. As a winner of several Nebula and Hugo Awards and the first person to receive a MacArthur Genius Grant for science fiction writing, she’s a towering figure in the genre. She was also a black woman, and unlike many other sci-fi icons of the 20th century—Clarke, Asimov, Dick, Atwood—none of her work has ever been adapted for film or TV. This includes her novel Kindred, which some people are recommending as an alternative to reading Underground Airlines.
In the article, The Magicians author Lev Grossman says, “This is a white writer going after questions of what it’s like to be black in America. It’s a fearless thing to do.”
Author and activist Daniel José Older countered on Twitter that that “fearlessness” mostly relates to criticism on social media. Winters’s career is unlikely to be in much danger as a result of writing this book, especially if he already has a TV adaptation in the works.
*being* a writer of color is risky and requires fearlessness.
Writing characters of color when you’re white means you get called brave.
— Daniel José Older (@djolder) July 5, 2016
Winters hasn’t directly responded the uproar on Twitter.
…and with that I’m going on a Twitter-cation for the time being…
— Ben H Winters (@BenHWinters) July 5, 2016
Gavia Baker-Whitelaw is a staff writer at the Daily Dot, covering geek culture and fandom. Specializing in sci-fi movies and superheroes, she also appears as a film and TV critic on BBC radio. Elsewhere, she co-hosts the pop culture podcast Overinvested.