New Yorker gets the realest note from stoner who found his wallet

Honesty hurts.


Miles Klee

Internet Culture

Published Feb 17, 2016   Updated May 27, 2021, 5:06 am CDT

I just moved to California from New York, and let me tell you—I’ve already forgotten what the subway is like. I have no memory of how winter feels. The rat race is is fast receding into distant history.

Featured Video Hide

But if one item could still conjure the city’s unmistakable aura for me, it’s this letter from the person who found New Yorker Reilly Flaherty’s lost wallet at a Wilco concert. Has anyone wrestling with their conscience ever achieved such transcendent honesty in the bargain?

Advertisement Hide

View this post on Instagram

thanks.. I think?

A post shared by reilly flaherty (@reillyflaherty) on

Flaherty had already replaced his “important stuff” by the time it was returned, he told the New York Post. “Anonymous” also filched a Barnes & Noble gift card and a loyalty card from Mr. Shiny’s shoeshine, “which was a real drag because I almost had a free shine,” he added. 

So, dear stoner, in the end you turned out to be not only selfish but basically unhelpful, despite your (not quite) best intentions. If you see Flaherty at the next indie rock show, at least give him a hit off that blunt.

H/T New York Post | Photo via reillyflaherty/Instagram

Share this article
*First Published: Feb 17, 2016, 4:06 pm CST