Fans think Luigi may be transgender

kob_critic/Twitter

The character has a lengthy history with gender nonconformity, too.

The internet’s thirstiest meme Bowsette isn’t actually canon, as it turns out. But don’t worry, fans have a new theory. Some think Luigi is transgender.

Last week, Nintendo published an official website for New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe, a Nintendo Switch rerelease for New Super Mario Bros. U and New Super Luigi U. The game features the so-called “Super Crown” for Toadette, which temporarily turns her into Peachette.

When the feature was originally announced, it spawned dozens of theories suggesting anyone could be feminized by the crown, hence Bowser becoming “Bowsette.” Now, several months later, the New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe website confirmed that only Toadette can use the crown, much to Luigi’s disappointment.

“When Toadette finds one of these, she can transform into the super-powered Peachette,” the website writes, before continuing, “(Sorry Luigi—only Toadette can use this item!)”

Nintendo’s joke about Luigi quickly grabbed fans’ attention. The aside seems to reference Toadette’s inclusion as an expansion character in New Super Luigi U for the Wii U, plus Luigi’s tendency to crossdress. But the Super Crown doesn’t just throw feminine clothes onto a character, it literally gives Toadette a feminine, Peach-like body. Plus, the comment sounds so pointed at Luigi that trans women began arguing Luigi wanted to put on the Super Crown to become a girl, not just dress as well.

Thus, through Bowsette’s canon death, a new theory was born: Luigi is trans. The idea quickly took off.

There’s plenty of art (and memes) floating around dedicated to the theory too.

https://twitter.com/kob_critic/status/1082040450222043139

For the record, there is some credence to the “Luigi is trans” theory. For one, there’s the “Mama Luigi” episode from the Super Mario World series, where Yoshi calls Luigi “mama.” Luigi proceeds to adopt the name, sparking the oft-repeated “Mama Luigi” meme.

Then there’s Luigi’s history with crossdressing. In Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga, Luigi crossdresses as Peach in order to trick Bowletta into releasing the real Princess Peach. Luigi similarly dressed up as Peach in Nintendo Power’s Super Mario Adventures comic, and he also considers wearing a dress in Luigi’s Mansion, saying dresses look “kind of comfortable.” At this point, Luigi’s gender nonconforming tendency to dress up in feminine attire is pretty expected.

Granted, people who choose to crossdress aren’t necessarily transgender, just gender nonconforming. But for some trans people, Luigi’s repeated fascination with dressing up as Peach or throwing on a dress represents a deeper desire, as if Luigi crossdresses as an outlet to express his gender identity.

In other words, trans people find it easy to argue that Luigi secretly (or not-so-secretly) wants to be a girl, and crossdressing is just one way to back up the theory. Twitter quickly embraced the idea.

https://twitter.com/nataliereed84/status/1081741156768047105

Others think the Super Crown line is just a reference to Luigi’s cross-dressing tendencies. After all, many crossdressers don’t identify as trans, hence fueling some skepticism against the theory.

For now, the internet can’t tell for certain whether Luigi is a girl, a crossdresser, or identifies in another way altogether. Nintendo for America declined to comment to the Daily Dot for this story.

But don’t let canon stop you. Clearly, Super Mario’s queer fans have an imagination powerful enough to create their own stories for Nintendo’s iconic characters. So go ahead, argue Luigi and Bowsette are trans. After all, sometimes fandom is the best way to express yourself.

Ana Valens

Ana Valens

Ana Valens is a reporter specializing in online queer communities, marginalized identities, and adult content creation. She is Daily Dot's Trans/Sex columnist. Her work has appeared at Vice, Vox, Truthout, Bitch Media, Kill Screen, Rolling Stone, and the Toast. She lives in Brooklyn, New York, and spends her free time developing queer adult games.