- This woman told two students to ‘speak English’ and people are not having it Friday 9:53 PM
- Iconic 1968 drag documentary ‘The Queen’ finally released on Netflix Friday 9:29 PM
- This TikTok account for Chancellor Palpatine is hilarious Friday 8:43 PM
- Did the Space Force logo rip off Star Trek? Friday 6:24 PM
- Disabled people with service dogs say Uber, Lyft drivers are denying them rides Friday 3:25 PM
- TikTok teen famous for greasy hair ends her 8-year reign Friday 2:48 PM
- Police handcuff brown man at subway station for carrying a toy gun Friday 1:20 PM
- Fake clip of Sanders quoting infamous ‘hot chip’ tweet is duping people online Friday 1:16 PM
- The Mars Volta’s Cedric Bixler-Zavala alleges Scientologists behind dog’s death Friday 12:46 PM
- Eminem responds to critics: ‘This album was not made for the squeamish’ Friday 12:42 PM
- ‘The poet, the poem’ meme takes iconic lines and turns them into art Friday 12:40 PM
- People are making dark memes about the coronavirus Friday 12:27 PM
- Trump camp’s ‘head on a pike’ impeachment threat hit with memes Friday 11:34 AM
- What is the #FreeBritney movement, and why is Cher tweeting about it? Friday 10:52 AM
- This YouTuber claims the Saudi government plotted to kidnap him on U.S. soil Friday 10:30 AM
Professional Call of Duty gamer FormaL was temporarily banned by Twitch because somebody on his stream used a homophobic slur. But FormaL, whose real name is Matthew Piper, was not the one to utter those words, and still, he got punished.
Which stunned him and much of the Twitch community.
“So confused right now, will let you guys know more when I do,” Piper tweeted on Monday. A couple hours later, he wrote, “I got suspended over something someone else said while I was playing with them. I’m currently trying to get it handled.”
According to esports consultant Rod Breslau, Piper’s original suspension was for a week because “a subscriber/another streamer of his used a homophobic slur on stream while playing together.”
Twitch has suspended professional Call of Duty player Formal's channel 7 days — through the launch of Modern Warfare — for a subscriber/another streamer of his used a homophobic slur on stream while playing together, according to a source— Rod Breslau (@Slasher) October 21, 2019
A couple hours later, though, Twitch unbanned him, meaning his 378,000 followers can continue to watch him ply his trade.
As Piper wrote on Monday evening, “We’re back, turns out there was some confusion about whether I was the one that said some hateful things or not but I got it cleared up. You guys know I’d never condone anything like that. See you tomorrow on stream!”
We're back, turns out there was some confusion about whether I was the one that said some hateful things or not but I got it cleared up. You guys know I'd never condone anything like that. See you tomorrow on stream!— LG FormaL (@FormaL) October 21, 2019
Twitch does not publicly comment on individual suspensions.
But this is certainly not the first time a Twitch ban (or lack thereof) has caused plenty of controversy. Plenty of women have been suspended for nudity even though they said it never happened or that it was accidental. Streamer Pink Ward was suspended earlier this year for apparently saying the N-word even though he was adamant he actually uttered the word “yikers.” And other Twitch users have been punished for things said by their followers. and not by them.
Plenty of people in the Twitch community were also outraged by the platform’s decision not to punish Alinity Divine after she threw her cat to the ground on a live stream.
As streamers and other Twitch users have constantly noted, Twitch’s punishments are inconsistent, and sometimes, they can affect a streamer who didn’t do anything wrong.
Josh Katzowitz is a staff writer at the Daily Dot specializing in YouTube and boxing. His work has appeared in the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post, and Los Angeles Times. A longtime sports writer, he's covered the NFL for CBSSports.com and boxing for Forbes. His work has been noted twice in the Best American Sports Writing book series.