Article Lead Image

Mike Kalasnik / Flickr (CC by 2.0) | Remix by Max Fleishman

9 unbelievable moments from the Hulk Hogan sex tape trial

This is getting intense, brother.


Miles Klee

Internet Culture

Posted on Mar 11, 2016   Updated on May 27, 2021, 2:39 am CDT

If the O.J. Simpson murder charge gave us the trial of the century, then wrestling legend Hulk Hogan‘s $100 million lawsuit against Gawker for publishing a secretly recorded video sex tape has the potential to become the trial of the millennium.  

That’s due in part to the far-reaching ramifications of how First Amendment rights play into the central narrative: Gawker’s lawyers claim that Hogan’s public status and candor about other sexual escapades made posting the video fair game. 

But let’s be real: What really makes this legal battle so Michael-Jackson-popcorn-GIF-worthy is that it’s Hulk Hogan (née Terry Bollea) suing someone over a sex tape. In Florida. And did we mention he’s having sex with the wife of a radio DJ known as Bubba the Love Sponge? 

And even though it’s far from over, the trial has already offered up a slew of iconic moments. Let’s review the very best (to date).

1) Jury selection

The court questioned hundreds of jurors over several days—and what a wild, wacky, painfully honest bunch they were.

(Though it’s also worth noting that the lawyers had to ask some fairly ridiculous questions.)

2) Hogan’s wardrobe

Opting for a formal black bandanna and prominent cross when appearing in court, Hogan has struck a look that recalls his days as Hollywood Hogan, when he led the New World Order, a (gimmick) insurrectionary group of wrestlers who threatened to subsume World Championship Wrestling and later World Wrestling Federation (now World Wrestling Entertainment).

3) The dick discrepancy (dickscrepancy)

“Hulk Hogan” is a fascinating personality insofar as it’s total fiction that continues 24/7—and on the witness stand, Terry Bollea admitted as much. In testifying about a sex tape and invasions of privacy, it’s only natural that genitalia would come up. When it did, the world learned something revelatory about the difference between Hogan’s dick and Bollea’s.

4) This cringeworthy exchange

A.J. Daulerio, Gawker’s editor-in-chief at the time of the fateful 2012 post, which he authored himself, gave a pretty weird answer in his deposition.

Anyone with a sex tape starring a famous 5-year-old, go ahead and send it to tips@gawker. The FBI will be with you shortly.

(OK, this reading isn’t quite fair to Daulerio, who was likely just defaulting to snark—no need to go full #Gamergate on him, fellas.)

5) Hogan’s big confession

The man has lived, by most accounts, a scandalous life, marred by headlines about his alleged racism, domestic abuse, and drug addictions. Somehow, amid all those exposures, his admission that he didn’t know how to use email in the year 2012 is the most jaw-dropping.

6) The reading of Gawker staffers’ dumb chat jokes

Max Read, Gawker’s editor-in-chief from March 2014 to July 2015, was a staff writer at the time of the Hogan sex tape post. He made a silly joke about it in Campfire, the software he and his co-workers used to chat throughout the day. That joke then had to be “explained” in a court of law, and Read was a trifle embarrassed about it

I worked at Gawker in 2012, but wasn’t involved in creating the story, so I’m not named in the lawsuit, nor was I deposed as a witness. But I did make jokes that involved Hogan in one way or another in our internal chat at the time. And now the whole world knows how corny I am.

The joke, which was the subject of a rigorous back-and-forth between [former Gawker editor-in-chief] John [Cook] and the opposing counsel, went something like this: Someone referred to the Hulk Hogan sex tape as “tender.” I wondered aloud if it also contained a leg drop (a famous pro-wrestling move) — a “tender leg drop.”

I can’t be much more specific than that, because I have no memory of making this joke. “Jokes I made to co-workers in 2012” is not a category I store prominently in my memory palace, though I love those co-workers and assure you that most of my jokes were much better. This is a scary realization: Hulk Hogan’s lawyers have a better sense of many conversations I had in 2012 than I do.

Lesson learned: Never talk to your co-workers.

7) The withering shade of Nick Denton

When asked if he was at all enthusiastic about getting ahold of the Hogan sex tape, a guaranteed traffic bonanza for the site, Gawker Media founder and overlord Nick Denton said he was more into a scoop about a college football player getting catfished. Ouch.

8) @Mobute’s coverage

Granted, none of this actually happened—but we can dream:

9) Brutus Beefcake

Brutus “The Barber” Beefcake, a wrestler and friend of Hogan’s, in 2011 vowed to sue Hogan’s ex-wife for claiming that the two men had indulged in a homosexual affair—a claim she later retracted. Seems the Gawker legal team wanted to draw some parallels between that incident and the case currently under review, but Hogan’s lawyers were not having it.  

Let the record show that a courageous attempt to drag someone called “Brutus Beefcake” into this circus was smacked down with extreme prejudice. A tragedy for scholars of law everywhere.

Photo via Mike Kalasnik/Flickr (CC BY 2.0) | Remix by Max Fleishman

Share this article
*First Published: Mar 11, 2016, 11:00 am CST