Rayshon Gartley

Civilian Office of Police Accountability Alex Dalbey

Charges dropped against cop filmed pummeling man during psych evaluation

Prosecutors allegedly contradicted the victim's story and blamed him for not cooperating.


Alex Dalbey


Posted on Jul 11, 2019   Updated on May 20, 2021, 8:53 am CDT

Criminal charges against a Chicago cop who was recorded hitting a handcuffed Chicago man Rayshon Gartley during a psychological evaluation have been dropped, the Root reports.

The case arose from an incident in 2014 in which Gartley was taken to Chicago’s Jackson Park Hospital for an involuntary psychological evaluation. His family had reportedly called the police because he was off his medication, and they needed help.

Surveillance video from the hospital, obtained by the organization Chicago Citizen Office of Police Accountability, shows a police officer marching a handcuffed Gartley into a room followed by a second cop. The first officer, Clauzell Gause, shoves Gartley into a wall, strikes him in the face, then knocks him onto a bed and begins repeatedly hitting him. As the first hospital staff member begins to round the corner into the room, Gause quickly stops and walks away from Gartley, and the second officer arranges Gartley on the bed.

Gartley brought a civil suit against the city for the alleged attack and was awarded $175,000 in 2018. As a result of that lawsuit, a criminal investigation was opened, and the Cook County State’s Attorney Office charged Gause with official misconduct.

Now, over five years after the violent encounter, prosecutors have dropped the charges against Gause, citing a lack of cooperation from Gartley. According to the Chicago Tribune, the state attorney’s office stated that it “cannot proceed and meet our burden without the testimony of Mr. Gartley.”

However, Gartley’s attorneys say that the prosecutor’s office didn’t try to contact them and that the prosecutors’ story is different from Gartley’s. The prosecutors say Gartley punched Gause first and then was placed in handcuffs. In his lawsuit, Gartley said he did not punch Gause but was instead being taunted in handcuffs before Gause brought him into the room where the recorded assault took place.

Even if Gartley did punch Gause before being placed in handcuffs, he was still in handcuffs when Gause attacked him, making “self-defense” pretty hard to claim. Gartley’s attorney, Andrew M. Stroth, says the video should have been more than enough evidence. “I think anyone could look at that video and make a determination that it’s excessive force,” Stroth told the Chicago Tribune. “I just think there’s other evidence that supports prosecution. … To just drop the charges? That’s not appropriate given the situation.”


Got five minutes? We’d love to hear from you. Help shape our journalism and be entered to win an Amazon gift card by filling out our 2019 reader survey.

H/T the Root

Share this article
*First Published: Jul 11, 2019, 12:55 pm CDT