- People are not falling for these ICE ‘propaganda’ photos Sunday 4:23 PM
- CLIF Bar and KIND Snacks are in a bizarre social media war Sunday 2:55 PM
- Caillou is how tall? Sunday 1:32 PM
- No, that video of a Boston Dynamics robot attacking its creators is not real Sunday 12:40 PM
- Alex Jones places $1 million bounty on culprit who planted child porn on his InfoWars server Sunday 12:03 PM
- ‘Stranger Things’ star’s new Netflix prank show is receiving backlash Sunday 9:04 AM
- How to watch ‘City on a Hill’ for free Sunday 8:00 AM
- How to watch ‘Euphoria’ for free Sunday 7:00 AM
- Meet the home brewer turning beer into a case for net neutrality Sunday 6:30 AM
- How to watch the U.S. vs. Chile at the World Cup for free Sunday 6:15 AM
- 15 teen movies on Netflix that will make you laugh, cry, and cringe Sunday 6:00 AM
- How to watch Estrella TV online for free Sunday 5:00 AM
- People are roasting this ‘traditional’ take on marriage with a hilarious meme Saturday 5:17 PM
- The internet just collectively realized that the Neopets of the world must be hungry Saturday 4:00 PM
- Alt-right message board 8chan was served a search warrant Saturday 3:06 PM
Your guide to the history, practice, and necessity of intersectionality.
If someone were to randomly ask me, “What are you?” I’d think they were asking me about my race—I’m Filipino and white, but those aren’t the only aspects of my identity that define me as a person. I’m also a heterosexual, cisgender woman. I’m an American citizen and an English speaker. And I’m able-bodied and generally neurotypical. All of these aspects of who I am affect one another, and make up the “intersection” of my identities. But is there an official intersectionality definition?
Within my work, in writing about race and identity, I know I must be intersectional and keep awareness of the perspective I write from. Though I have first-hand experience understanding gender discrimination and gender violence as a woman, my race, even being multi-racial and at times racially ambiguous, has protected me from experiencing anti-Black racism. Being heterosexual and cisgender allows me to exist in the world without being questioned about that existence. Being an able-bodied person, I’ve had no trouble with accessibility and moving through the world, be it through public spaces or with public transportation.
I think about these aspects of my own life as I write, knowing I only have a certain perspective through which I’ve gone through certain experiences, and use this awareness to make my writing more inclusive of the intersectionality of identities I do not share.
So, what is intersectionality? How do these intersections affect how we move through the world, and how people see us? And what does it mean to “be intersectional” in everyday life?
What is the definition of intersectionality?
“Intersectionality,” as defined by Merriam-Webster’s dictionary in 2017, is “the complex, cumulative manner in which the effects of different forms of discrimination (such as racism, sexism, and classism) combine, overlap, or intersect”—especially in the experiences of marginalized people or groups.
While intersectionality is often applied to the intersection of racism and sexism, other forms of discrimination include discrimination based upon class, sexuality, ability, and age.
Teaching Tolerance, a resource for schools and educators from the Southern Poverty Law Center, further explains the basics of intersectionality with a video titled “Intersectionality 101.”
“Life isn’t the same for everyone—even for people who share identity characteristics,” the video summarizes. “By adopting an intersectional lens, we have a better opportunity to understand why and to change the institutions that help and harm us based on who we are.”
Where does the concept of intersectionality come from?
According to an incorrect interpretation of her speech at the Woman’s Rights Convention on May 29, 1851, Sojourner Truth first posed the question: “Ain’t I a woman?” It was a notable example of intersectionality.
Delivered more than a decade before the Civil War and the abolition of slavery, Truth’s speech juxtaposed the rapidly expanding movement for women’s rights with the stagnant oppression of racism under slavery. Having worked in slavery, Truth said she had as much muscle as a man and could work and eat as much as a man. Though she is equal to a man in every physical way, wasn’t she also a woman, therefore proving that women are equal to men? Or did the intersectionality of her race and gender discount her experience as a woman altogether?
Despite its popularity and resonance, the phrase was never uttered by Truth at all, according to the Sojourner Truth Project. This version of the speech was constructed by Frances Dana Gage in 1863, nearly 12 years after Truth’s speech, and differs greatly from the version Marius Robinson, a friend of Truth’s, first transcribed and printed with Truth’s approval in 1851. The phrase isn’t completely ahistorical: It stems from an abolitionist campaign slogan, “Am I not a woman and a sister?” The intent of Truth’s speech was still about intersectionality.
- The dirty, complex, empowering history of the word ‘queer’
- What it means to be transgender
- The pride and pitfalls in LGBTQ labels
- What does cisgender mean—and what is cisgender privilege?
The evolution of intersectionality
Along with Truth, writer Anna Julia Cooper is another frequently-cited authority on early mentions of intersectionality, with her essay “The Colored Woman’s Office.”
Penned in 1892, Cooper’s piece explores the importance of Black women in social movements on the basis of their experience with multiple forms of discrimination. W. E. B. Du Bois’ writing too examined the intersections of race, class, and nation and how they affected the African-American community’s access to status, poverty, and power, though Du Bois’ analysis did not involve the role of gender. bell hooks’ 1981 book Ain’t I A Woman: Black Women and Feminism, invoking Truth’s speech, also explores how racism and sexism within slavery went on to affect civil rights and feminist movements.
Intersectionality first appears as a cited term
It was legal scholar Kimberlé Crenshaw, however, who first coined the term “intersectionality theory” in her 1989 essay, “Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics.”
In the essay, Crenshaw analyzes the ways in which Black women have been historically discounted for the intersections of their race, gender, and class through legal sex and discrimination cases, the feminist and civil rights movements, and media representation. For example, Crenshaw wrote that Black women are either considered “too much like women or Blacks” to the point of making their experiences “too different” from the goals of both the feminist and Black liberation movements, pushing the perspectives and needs of Black women to the margins of both.
Crewshaw also drew upon Truth’s “Ain’t I a Woman,” speech in her essay. At the time of Truth’s speech, white women had urged that Truth remain silent. They feared that she’d divert attention from the women’s suffrage movement to the emancipation of slaves. According to Crenshaw, Truth challenged both the patriarchy and white womanhood by calling attention to the ways in which men and white women saw women such as Truth as someone “different” from “real women.”
Black feminism and intersectionality
Through the 1990s, sociologist Patricia Hill Collins brought intersectionality into prominence with her writing on Black feminism. In a speech she delivered at Montgomery College in 2017, she explored how Black feminist intersectionality shapes the imagination around democratic possibilities for the future and how marginalized groups should support one another.
- Breaking down the difference between gender identity and sex
- What does it mean to be genderqueer?
- Trans and nonbinary people explain what gender dysphoria feels like
- Here’s what it really means to be asexual
What are some examples of intersectionality?
Intersectionality can be applied to any number of topics, such as politics, education, and healthcare.
For one example, in 2016 the Obama administration added transgender students under the classification of gender identities protected under Title IX. In including transgender students under this protection, the administration brought transgender students into mainstream conversations about discrimination. The Trump administration has since rescinded protections for transgender students.
Another example is in Texas, where Black mothers have the highest rate of dying as a result of pregnancy in the state. Between 2012 and 2015, Black women delivered only 11 percent of the babies in the state, but they made up 20 percent of these maternal deaths, the Texas Tribune reported. In healthcare, doctors can make their practices more intersectional by acknowledging and addressing this alarming race discrepancy. They can push for reforms that seek to close this gap and provide better healthcare for Black women in addition to all mothers.
In politics, groups like EMILY’s List, Annie’s List, She Should Run provide opportunities for women—particularly women of color—to run for office. By making public office more accessible, these organizations are paying attention to the intersectionality of gender, race, and class.
How can we become more intersectional in our activism?
Today, we see women continue to campaign for feminism with the awareness that they are not only pushing for women’s equality for white women, but also for women of color, women of different sexualities, and women with different abilities.
Still, major liberal political movements are often criticized for failing to craft the movement around the intersectionality of all members. Some critics of the first Women’s March took issue with its partnerships with anti-abortion organizations. Others criticized signage that focused solely on female sexual organs as a symbol of women’s rights, which espoused anti-transgender beliefs. This is also often referred to as “trans-exclusionary radical feminism.”
While it’s obviously easier said than done, movements can be more intersectional by analyzing the movement’s issues in relation to people of different backgrounds. The Black Lives Matter movement can acknowledge and advocate for the experiences of Black women and queer and transgender Black people instead of only Black men. The Women’s March can acknowledge and advocate for the experiences of trans women. And organizations can start by putting those people in positions of power and organization.
Activist movements can also work toward being more accessible to people of different abilities and languages. For example, during live events or in videos, sign language interpreters and captions should be standard. Events and demonstrations should be held at spaces with ramps and designated seating for people who need mobility accommodations.
Editor’s note: This article is regularly updated for relevance.
Samantha Grasso is a former IRL staff writer for the Daily Dot with a reporting emphasis on immigration. Her work has appeared on Los Angeles Magazine, Death And Taxes, Revelist, Texts From Last Night, Austin Monthly, and she has previously contributed to Texas Monthly.