Surprising few, the elusive filmmaker Laura Poitras received an Academy Award for Best Documentary Feature for her film Citizenfour, which follows her journey with journalist Glenn Greenwald to greet and debrief Snowden in Hong Kong. She was joined on stage by Greenwald, Citizenfour producer Dirk Wilutzky and editor Mathilde Bonnefoy, and much to everyone’s surprise, Lindsay Mills, Snowden’s girlfriend who now lives with him in Moscow.
“The disclosures that Ed Snowden revealed don’t only expose a threat to privacy but to our democracy itself,” Poitras said upon receiving her Oscar. “When the most important decisions … [that] affected all of us are made in secret, we lose our ability to check the powers that control,” she said.
As Poitras and her colleagues departed the stage, Harris, a.k.a. “NPH” made his quip:
“The subject of Citizenfour, Edward Snowden, could not be here tonight for some treason.”
Snowden is charged with three felonies, including espionage, but is not charged with treason. Either way, Snowden supporters on Twitter did not find his joke funny.
Is it me or was NPH's zinger about Snowden's 'treason' in bad taste given they just gave citizenfour an #Oscar?— Gibran Ashraf (@GibranAshraf) February 23, 2015
Profoundly disappointed in the “for some treason” joke from NPH.— Wil 'this account mocks fascists' Wheaton (@wilw) February 23, 2015
Edward Snowden is a patriot, who stood up for all Americans.
NPH does a treason pun seconds after Citizen4 wins. Weak bid for a laugh that didn't come. Time for an intervention. #Oscars2015— Mick LaSalle (@MickLaSalle) February 23, 2015
NPH's worst bomb was the treason joke.— Lorax B. Horne (@bbhorne) February 23, 2015
NPH you're dead to me for some treason— Robert Greene (@prewarcinema) February 23, 2015
A few people, however, found the value in NPH’s pun, even while still supporting Snowden as a whistleblower:
Kudos to whistleblowers AND NPH for his pun "treason!" #Oscars2015— Pookiedook (@pookiedookies) February 23, 2015
I laughed at the “treason” joke. Snowden’s no traitor, but that was funny. And NPH also made fun of Meryl Streep. Nothing off limits.— Eric Boehm (@EricBoehm87) February 23, 2015
Snowden’s leaked documents have caused a wave of controversy for more than a year and a half, sparking widespread debate over the National Security Agency’s (NSA) mass surveillance capabilities. Snowden currently resides in Russia, and many fear that returning to the United States may mean a secret trial and life behind bars for the 31-year-old.
Last week, Snowden’s leaked files played an instrumental role in revealing that the British and American governments have potentially compromised billions of cellphone SIM cards worldwide.
Update: This article has been updated to provide additional clarity and context.
Photo by Disney ABC Television Group/Flickr (CC BY-ND 2.0)