- Twitch streamer inadvertently documents all the times she was sexually, verbally harassed on vacation 6 Years Ago
- Raptors coach Nick Nurse becomes a relatable meme 6 Years Ago
- Man wears bandage that blends in with his skin tone, and Twitter has all the feelings 6 Years Ago
- The 8 best Korean sunscreens to add to your bag Today 12:15 PM
- New ‘Avengers: Endgame’ commercials drop a few big spoilers Today 11:58 AM
- 11 party games for people sick of playing Cards Against Humanity Today 11:45 AM
- Curvy Wife Guy makes the most Curvy Wife Guy pregnancy announcement Today 11:31 AM
- ‘A Fortunate Man’ is a gorgeous, shallow adaptation of a classic novel Today 11:30 AM
- Obama’s ‘Easter worshippers’ tweet upsets conservatives Today 11:04 AM
- Trump responds to impeachment calls: ‘You can’t’ Today 10:43 AM
- Desperate YouTuber goes on ‘holy pilgrimage’ to meet PewDiePie Today 10:33 AM
- Influencer faces 20 years for hiring cousin to threaten man into giving up domain name Today 10:17 AM
- ‘Avengers: Endgame’ isn’t actually the end of Marvel’s Phase 3 Today 10:12 AM
- ‘Star Trek: Discovery’ just obliterated every stupid argument about its place in canon Today 9:24 AM
- ‘Game of Thrones’ brings us lots of horny Tormund memes Today 8:46 AM
The Daily Beast’s op-ed about Chelsea Manning in jail is a tasteless prison fantasy.
The Daily Beast ran an op-ed titled “How Will Chelsea Manning Be Treated in Prison,” written by a former federal prison inmate, Mansfield Frazier. The piece is a personal one, and he begins with this scene:
The most bloodcurdling sound I’ve ever heard came from the throat of a prisoner as a 10-gallon vat of boiling-hot cooking oil was dumped on his head in the chow hall at Kentucky’s Ashland federal prison. The man—a huge, strapping bodybuilder—had slapped a small, effeminate gay inmate two days prior for laughing at him as he busted out of a poker game.
Frazier’s piece attempts to sketch out how Manning—who today announced she will be living life as a woman, and possibly undergoing hormone replacement treatment while imprisoned at Fort Leavenworth—might fare in prison as a transgender person. Frazier says that in his “personal experience serving time in federal prisons—and in contrast with the horrible images of repeated sexual assault that many have no doubt conjured up already—transgender and gay inmates are often treated quite well.”
Of course, Frazier was in a federal prison, and Manning will be in a military prison.
In the very next sentence, Frazier cites a 2012 report from the Department of Justice and adds, “more than a third of transgender former inmates were sexually assaulted in prison. The same report found that transgender women are 13 times more likely to be assaulted than other inmates.” An editor’s note was added to the blog after publication, clarifying that it is an opinion piece, and inaccurate. The editor added actual prison rape statistics, which were largely left out of the original.
Update: The Daily Beast cut two controversial sections of the op-ed, reproduced below. In the second paragraph, the author claims gay men often return to prison because of the sex:
The piece still comes off like a tasteless prison fantasy, or a pitch for a new TV show. Frazier goes on to toss out potential “relationship” situations in prison, and explains how a particularly savvy inmate could become “prison rich” via sexual favors. This is the well-scrubbed picture of prison-rape culture. It’s a business, even.
Many are calling for the removal of the piece:
Hey @thedailybeast! Good editors note but you spelled “Sorry for posting hateful lies about rape and we are closing down forever” wrong.
— Jamie Kilstein (@jamiekilstein) August 22, 2013
By tomorrow morning that Daily Beast article will consist of the word “The” and a seven-part, 2500-word editor’s note.
— Angus Johnston (@studentactivism) August 22, 2013
The last paragraph is especially awful:
One thing is almost a certainty: celibacy probably won’t be an option for Chelsea Manning, but she will have choices in regard to how she wants to spend her years behind bars. With that said, we need to keep in mind that one person’s prison is another person’s palace. Chelsea Manning could become the queen bee.
Yes, prison might be a palace for Manning. A palace where celibacy isn’t an option, which is another way or saying Manning might be raped, or suggesting she might be OK with that, with her “queen bee” status and all. Worse than the tawdry, sensational tone of the piece, it added nothing to the conversation about prison abuse, rape culture, or transgender issues.
Photo via savebradley/Flickr
Audra Schroeder is the Daily Dot’s senior entertainment writer, and she focuses on streaming, comedy, and music. Her work has previously appeared in the Austin Chronicle, the Dallas Observer, NPR, ESPN, Bitch, and the Village Voice. She is based in Austin, Texas.