Model and cookbook author Chrissy Teigen has been under fire all morning after tweeting that she isn’t that offended when people use the word “oriental” in reference to Asian people. And it all started with salad dressing.
Last night, Teigen tweeted that she was weirded out that there was an option for “oriental dressing” for a meal on her flight. She acknowledged that it’s an antiquated term, but that it has no place on a modern menu.
I really really really really clearly am not a PC type of gal but I'm a little weirded out at the oriental dressing option on my flight— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
Like if you're over 50 you can call me oriental to my face but this is a new menu and I'm not a rug— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
From there, someone asked if the term “oriental” is offensive, to which she replied that she thought of it as more “old school,” and that while she’s not outright offended, no one should be using it anymore. Teigen chalked up its usage to “forgivable ignorance.”
Not offensive, really. Just weird. Old school. Just say Asian. https://t.co/yXOhPfwCJ6— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
It's not a slur, though. It's just a bit of forgivable ignorance. https://t.co/SGFEPLvwrQ— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
Teigen, whose mother is Thai, also says it would be weird but not wrong to call her mother “Siamese,” since Thailand used to be Siam (though it’s unclear if that was what it was called when Teigen’s mother was born).
For instance, you can call my mother Siamese. Thailand was Siam. But yeah. A little weird now.— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
Earlier this year, President Obama signed a bill prohibiting the use of the words “negro” and “oriental” in federal documents, to which New York Congresswoman Grace Meng commented, “At long last, this insulting and outdated term will be gone for good.”
To break it down simply, the word Orient means East and is used as a catchall phrase for anything “Eastern,” which in a “Western”-centric world means Asia. That centering of the West, and generalizing of an entire continent of cultures into one demonym, are what many find offensive. Teigen argues that it’s outdated, and that she can’t be offended by someone who doesn’t know that Asian-American (or, you know, the demonym of a specific country) is the preferred nomenclature. But others say that intent doesn’t matter if the end result is offensive.
Ignorance without malice isn't something I can be offended by.— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
The argument between intent and impact is central to many discussions about racism, because few people set out in their everyday lives to be racist. Instead, racism comes from ignorance, from not questioning learned behaviors, and from refusing to refer to people the way they want to be referred.
For instance, some Asian people have defended the use of “oriental.” In an essay for NPR, Kat Chow says her father, who immigrated to America from Hong Kong in 1969, uses “oriental” to describe himself. “‘We use Asian, or Asian-American, now,’ I’ll tell him. ‘That term’s been outdated for a long time.’ He just shrugs.” In an op-ed for the LA Times, Jayne Tsuchiyama writes, “Apparently Asians are supposed to feel demeaned if someone refers to us as Orientals. But good luck finding a single Asian-American who has ever had the word spat at them in anger.”
However, there is a big difference between how someone chooses to refer to themselves or within a group, and acceptable common usage as a whole (just look at every conversation around the N word). This is something Teigen recognizes.
I really appreciate all the non-Asians telling me what is offensive to Asians, though. Thank you. Writing it all down.— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
Do I think saying "oriental" is inappropriate? Yes. Laughable and ignorant. Am I OFFENDED when I hear it? No.— christine teigen (@chrissyteigen) September 13, 2016
So, to recap, Chrissy Teigen doesn’t like the word “oriental,” understands the reason it’s offensive to others, but doesn’t feel personally offended if someone uses it out of ignorance. Seems like…not the worst?