Article Lead Image

Allison Williams of ‘Girls’ will play Peter Pan on NBC

Are you having a good morning? Well, good for you. That’s all gonna change.


EJ Dickson


Posted on Jul 30, 2014   Updated on May 30, 2021, 8:58 pm CDT

Are you having a good morning? Commute to work went smoothly? Boss said you looked nice today, and you’re generally in a good mood? Well, good for you. That’s all gonna change in about three to five seconds, when you find out that Allison Williams, a.k.a. Marnie on Girls, has been cast as Peter Pan in NBC’s musical production of Peter Pan.

Didn’t catch that? Let’s try this again: Allison Williams, an actress who is primarily known for being A) Brian Williams’s daughter, and B) the prettiest, least interesting, and best-eyebrowed cast member of Girls, has been cast as Peter Pan in NBC’s musical adaptation of Peter Pan. She’ll be playing the role alongside Christopher Walken, who’s been cast as Captain Hook.

Try to think lovely thoughts, guys. Think lovely thoughts.

Via Entertainment Weekly:

“We couldn’t be happier that Allison Williams is our Peter Pan,” said NBC chief Robert Greenblatt. “She’s a lovely rising star on the award-winning show Girls—where she occasionally shows off her incredible vocal talent—and we think she will bring the perfect blend of ‘boyish’ vulnerability and bravado to save the day against Christopher Walken’s powerful Captain Hook.”

Naturally, the Internet is not happy that Williams, who along with her Girls castmates has been frequently accused of being the beneficiary of nepotism, has been cast in of the most famous theater roles of all time, a role that was famously originated on Broadway by musical theater legend Mary Martin.

who dreamed this RT @nbc: Dreams do come true! #Girls star Allison Williams will play Peter Pan in #PeterPanLive!

— LW (@lindseyweber) July 30, 2014

“Who?” – Mary Martin FROM HER GRAVE

— Caroline Moss (@socarolinesays) July 30, 2014

“Allison Williams does nothing for me.” “Allison Williams does nothing for everyone.”

— Tyler Coates (@tylercoates) July 30, 2014

She’s more of a Smee. RT @nbc: Dreams do come true! #Girls star Allison Williams will play Peter Pan in #PeterPanLive

— Slade Sohmer (@SladeHV) July 30, 2014

NBC casts Allison Williams as Peter Pan. Maybe they can find a guest role for Brian?

— James Poniewozik (@poniewozik) July 30, 2014

It’s not that Allison Williams can’t sing, as she’s demonstrated on various episodes of Girls. (Not to mention in a series of nauseating musical theater covers she shot while she was in college, which are all available to watch/cringe at on YouTube). It’s that her flinty, weak soprano is totally inappropriate for the role of Peter Pan, which requires a big, booming voice and presence. 

It’ll be interesting to see whether her turn as Peter Pan will be as poorly received as Carrie Underwood’s portrayal of Maria—a role also originated by Mary Martin—in last year’s The Sound of Music Live!, but I think I speak for most of us musical-theater lovers when I say the following:

H/T Entertainment Weekly | Screengrab via Larry King/YouTube

Share this article
*First Published: Jul 30, 2014, 10:42 am CDT