The truth about that viral Bill Nye screengrab

These iOS 13 features will have you racing to update your iPhone on Sept. 19
Bill Nye, the Science Guy, is back in his new Netflix series, Bill Nye Saves the World, and the internet is filling up with choice screengrabs of Bill (Bill! Bill!). One of these viral quotes has become especially controversial, because it seems to show that Nye, beloved by science-respecting liberals, is a hypocrite on issues of […]

See all Editor's Picks

Bill Nye, the Science Guy, is back in his new Netflix series, Bill Nye Saves the World, and the internet is filling up with choice screengrabs of Bill (Bill! Bill!). One of these viral quotes has become especially controversial, because it seems to show that Nye, beloved by science-respecting liberals, is a hypocrite on issues of gender. Don’t worry, though, friends of Bill, because it’s a big ‘ol fake.

Here’s the meme that seems to show Nye in 1995 claiming that gender is strictly a matter of chromosomes, then changing his mind on the new show, coming around to the position that gender is a spectrum.

bill nye gender quote: fake imade of bill nye on gender Image via not_liquid/Reddit

 

The middle graphic, of money changing hands, implies that Bill Nye was paid by someone, perhaps some liberal “social justice warrior” cabal, to take a more trans-friendly position. The thing is, Nye never took the gender-essentialist position in the first place.

“Nye never said, ‘Gender is determined by your chromosomes’ in that particular episode of his old show. The text in the now-widely shared image comes via some random Internet user,” according to the Washington ExaminerThe site linked to the old episode of Nye’s show, so you can see what he really said:

“Our genes are stories in parts of our cells called chromosomes. Chromosomes contain all of the genetic information; all the instructions you need to make a person. Now humans have 23 pairs of chromosomes for a total of 46. It’s like the instructions are stored in 46 books and the books are divided into chapters, and each chapter is like a gene.”

Nothing about gender there at all.

What appears to be the first instance of the Bill Nye genders meme was posted to Reddit’s r/dankmemes, where posters tend to be obsessed with, and make jokes about, the idea that “there are only 2 genders.”

general grievous gender collection meme crosbay/Reddit

columbine shooters only 2 genders meme generalgerbilovsky/Reddit

In that environment, this bogus Nye meme was a surefire way to gain a pile of Reddit karma, the site’s “fake internet points.” Indeed, it made it nearly to the top of the subreddit and garnered more than 400 comments (most posts don’t even crack 10).

Many of them pointed out that the top screengrab is fake, but some just expressed disappointment in Nye for ruining their childhoods with his progressive-ish ideas about the gender spectrum.

The original poster, not_liquid, acknowledged that the caption on the older screengrab was fabricated, but defended his meme regardless:

“To all of you saying it’s fake, it is. It’s just a meme. Memes aren’t supposed to be facts or quotes, they’re supposed to be dank.”

The last quote in the meme, about Nye believing gender belongs on a spectrum, is real. Because scientists are woke.

Jay Hathaway

Jay Hathaway

Jay Hathaway is a former senior writer who specialized in internet memes and weird online culture. He previously served as the Daily Dot’s news editor, was a staff writer at Gawker, and edited the classic websites Urlesque and Download Squad. His work has also appeared on nymag.com, suicidegirls.com, and the Morning News.