- The creepy texts this woman received are eerily similar to Netflix’s ‘You’ Today 4:20 PM
- Roku defends decision to host InfoWars amid online backlash Today 4:04 PM
- Pump yourself up for ‘Game of Thrones’ season 8 with this masterfully edited hype video Today 2:35 PM
- NBC asked reporters not to call Steve King’s comments ‘racist’ Today 2:21 PM
- Disney files copyright claim on YouTuber’s Darth Vader film—and the creator is devastated Today 2:18 PM
- The ’10 Year Challenge’ isn’t as fun for trans people Today 1:25 PM
- New Nike shoes can be controlled from your smartphone Today 1:06 PM
- Cardi B. jumps on 10-year challenge with high school performance of Lady Gaga song Today 12:28 PM
- Parents, teachers cry foul over Verizon fee hike for popular education app Today 11:57 AM
- Conservative men are kicking and screaming about Gillette’s new toxic masculinity ad Today 11:23 AM
- Mysterio is hot now in the ‘Spider-Man: Far From Home’ trailer Today 10:53 AM
- Netflix hikes prices on all subscription plans Today 10:48 AM
- Ajit Pai is refusing to testify about cell phone tracking data Today 10:18 AM
- Murder is back on the menu with Netflix’s Ted Bundy documentary Today 9:53 AM
- Twitch star Alinity Divine accidentally displays d*ck pic on her stream Today 9:18 AM
Why Hollywood filmmakers need to stop advertising LGBTQ characters who don’t exist
Filmmakers are just making things harder for themselves.
After hinting that Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 includes an LGBTQ character, writer/director James Gunn is trying to correct the record. “We don’t really know who’s gay and who’s not [in the Marvel franchise],” Gunn told Digital Spy. “It could be any of them.”
Then, he gave an interview that prompted the Guardian headline, “There are gay characters in the Marvel Universe.”
“What I meant is, there’s a lot of characters in the MCU, and very few of them have we delved into what their sexuality is. Whether it’s guy or straight or bisexual, we don’t really know. So I imagine that there are probably, you know, gay characters in the Marvel universe, we just don’t know who they are yet.”
By continuing to answer these questions, Gunn puts himself in an awkward position. Because in reality, there aren’t any LGBTQ characters “in the MCU.” Those characters could just as easily be androids or aliens. James Gunn is talking in distant hypotheticals, but LGBTQ representation requires some actual commitment onscreen.
Gunn is the latest filmmaker to publicly support LGBTQ representation in theory, while failing to follow up in practice. The most infamous example is Beauty and the Beast director Bill Condon, whose “exclusively gay moment” turned out to be a split-second shot of two men dancing in a crowd scene. Power Rangers barely did better, dedicating a ton of publicity to a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it line where a female character says she has “girlfriend problems.”
Filmmakers like Gunn and Condon see the enthusiasm for LGBTQ representation, and offer subtext in response. The problem is, LGBTQ audiences are already very familiar with subtext, because that’s all they usually get.
Gunn’s example was particularly ridiculous, because after seeing Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2, I’m pretty sure I know which character he was talking about. There’s a scene where a woman rejects a man because he’s not “her type,” in a way that could refer to his gender, his species, or any number of other reasons. In the context of the MCU, it’s less noticeable than the queer subtext between Captain America and Bucky Barnes, a relationship that provided the driving force for three movies. Subtext isn’t always intentional, and it’s not the same as representation.
In Gunn’s defense, this situation is only partly his fault. If a blockbuster like Guardians of the Galaxy had a gay protagonist, it wouldn’t get released in China, a highly desirable overseas market. Given a choice between LGBTQ representation and the Chinese market, studios will invariably follow the money. It’s just embarrassing when filmmakers want to toe the line of homophobic censorship, and be celebrated as progressive at the same time.
Gavia Baker-Whitelaw is a staff writer at the Daily Dot, covering geek culture and fandom. Specializing in sci-fi movies and superheroes, she also appears as a film and TV critic on BBC radio. Elsewhere, she co-hosts the pop culture podcast Overinvested.