- Bug lets Twitter save your DMs—even after you delete them Friday 7:21 PM
- Guy mansplains song to Japanese Breakfast, the female artist who wrote the song Friday 6:38 PM
- Ann Coulter’s Twitter bio links to a vulgar parody account Friday 5:22 PM
- Popular YouTube music channel gets income yanked for ‘repetitious’ content Friday 4:14 PM
- New website will endlessly generate fake faces thanks to AI Friday 3:41 PM
- Man fakes getting stood up at Outback Steakhouse Friday 3:03 PM
- FCC looks to tackle robocalls and spoofed texts Friday 2:57 PM
- How to protect yourself from the data breach that affected 744 million accounts Friday 12:56 PM
- How to stream Rob Brant vs. Khasan Baysangurov online for free Friday 12:21 PM
- No, Ocasio-Cortez doesn’t have her boyfriend on her payroll Friday 12:20 PM
- Writers want this book canceled for misgendering its protagonist Friday 12:15 PM
- Trump Jr’s meme about his dad’s border wall doesn’t get how Congress works Friday 11:44 AM
- FBI reportedly looking into Ryan Adams’ communications with underage girl Friday 11:25 AM
- Trump does Chinese accent, declares national emergency, bewilders the internet Friday 11:21 AM
- Chrissy Teigen throws shade at Logan Paul-Kaitlin Bennett pairing Friday 10:48 AM
It looks like a new study made Pinterest look like it offered more referral traffic than it really did.
Pinterest is one of the hottest properties online. But does it really drive more visitors than Twitter?
The study tech journalists cited was by Shareaholic, an online sharing tool. You know those cartoony share buttons you often see at the bottom of blog posts? That’s Shareaholic’s product. Every time someone clicks a button, Shareaholic records a referral.
And that’s where the study falls apart. It only reported the behavior of Shareaholics customers.
Reddit provides a perfect case study.
From Dec. 11 to Jan. 12 the social news site dropped in Shareaholic’s rankings, from 1.13 to .83 percent of total traffic.Yet at the same time, the site recorded a million-visitor boost in its own traffic, from about 35 million unique visitors in Dec. to 36 million in Jan.
Reddit disappeared entirely from Shareaholic’s February report. So that leaves us wondering: How could Reddit drive so much less referral traffic even as it’s growing so quickly?
Either Reddit is actually driving less traffic, or people are no longer sharing on Reddit via Shareaholic. We don’t know. And that’s the whole problem. The study is completely unscientific. A more accurate title would have been: “Pinterest drives more traffic than Twitter among Shareaholic customers.”
According to Shareaholic, those customers include 200,000 publishers who drive more than 270 million unique visitors a month globally. But who are these publishers? And how are they in any way a representative sampling of the Internet as a whole?
Add another complicating factor: Pinterest is a closed book.
The company rarely responds to media inquiries, citing the fact that it has yet to hire a press person, and has turned down all but three interview requests in 2012. Two were with bloggers. Hard data on Pinterest is next to impossible to find.
Blogger Josh Davis is one of the few to penetrate Pinterest’s facade. After his blog post on Pinterest’s tie to affiliate program Skimlinks threatened to cause panic among users, cofounder Ben Silbermann called him personally for an interview.
When we spoke to Davis earlier this month, he said he disapproved of the startup’s tight-lipped media strategy. He said that tech journalists aren’t equipped to act as authorities yet and, without getting the facts from Pinterest, their slip-ups might spread misinformation.
“I would say that most people reporting on Pinterest especially in the mainstream digital/tech press likely don’t use the service enough to really understand how Pinterest works,” he told the Daily Dot previously. “I spent and hour on the phone with one of the writers of the Wall Street Journal article on Pinterest and she hadn’t even heard of the service until the day before.”
Given the nature of the study and the fact that Pinterest data is virtually unavailable It’s no wonder that Shareaholic’s data duped so many (including the Daily Dot).
Pinterest did not respond to the Daily Dot’s request for comment.
Lauren Rae Orsini contributed to this report.
Photo by 27147
Kevin Morris is a veteran web reporter and editor who specializes in longform journalism. He led the Daily Dot’s esports vertical and, following its acquisition by GAMURS in late 2016, launched Dot Esports, where he serves as the site’s editor-in-chief.