woman in pink hoody in Best Buy parking lot

Mike Mozart/Flickr Reynoldsburg Division Of Police/Facebook (CC-BY) Remix by Jason Reed

Internet trolls police who asked for help identifying Best Buy thief

The alleged thief's picture went viral.


David Britton

Internet Culture

Published Feb 1, 2018   Updated May 22, 2021, 2:25 am CDT

Police in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, needed a little help finding a woman who allegedly stole an Xbox and PlayStation gaming console from a local Best Buy. So what better way to find the possible thief than by posting her picture to Facebook? NBC4 out of Columbus even helped out by sharing the photo on their Twitter account.

But the internet is a fickle mistress. If you ask it a question, there’s no telling what kind of answers you’ll get. There was something about this picture that captured people’s imaginations. Maybe it was the fact that this photo—unlike the blurry security cam shots we’re used to—was crystal clear. Maybe it’s this woman’s quizzical expression (despite her lack of eyebrows) or that she seems to be pushing an imaginary shopping cart. It might have had something to do with the description that accompanied the Facebook post:



On 1/29/18 at 1:50 PM, the female in this photo committed a felony theft offense at the the Reynoldsburg Best Buy in Taylor Square.


This suspect was accompanied by a white male and a white female and stole both Xbox and Play Station game consoles. The suspects left in an older rusty silver Honda Civic.


If you can identify the female in the photograph, or have any information about this crime, contact Officer Manny

Whatever the reason, people seemed much more interested in mocking the woman than helping police capture her.

console theft comment 1
console thief comments 2
console theft comments 3
console theft comments 4

It turns out all the jokes were helpful. The post was shared over 800 times—and the woman and her friends were arrested.

UPDATEThanks to our followers on social media Officer Manny has identified the suspects. THEFT SUSPECTOn 1/29/18…

Posted by Reynoldsburg Division Of Police on Tuesday, January 30, 2018

No word on whether the consoles (or eyebrows) were recovered.

Share this article
*First Published: Feb 1, 2018, 3:51 pm CST