mayo pete with mayor pete

chrisdorney/Shutterstock Gage Skidmore/Flickr DPRPapaJohns/reddit (Licensed) Remix by Jason Reed

Everyone’s seen the ‘Mayo Pete’ memes except Pete Buttigieg

He's not sure he wants to know.


Claire Goforth

Internet Culture

Posted on Jan 16, 2020   Updated on May 19, 2021, 5:41 pm CDT

In advance of announcing its endorsement for the Democratic presidential primary, the New York Times editorial board is publishing transcripts of its interviews with the candidates.

The Times’ interview with former South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg included a question he definitely didn’t see coming. “How do you counter the ‘Mayo Pete’ memes?” asked Aisha Harris.

Buttigieg claimed ignorance of the memes, which are popular on TikTok. Young TikTok users use it to roast him and his campaign song, “High Hopes” by Panic! At the Disco, and especially the accompanying dance.

“Do I want to know?” he asked.

The board explained that the memes basically imply that Buttigieg is white and bland, to which he replied, “I get the white part.”

He went on to make a stump-tested soliloquy about healthcare reform, carbon emissions, and college tuition. But all some readers could focus on was that Mayo Pete part.

Online reactions ranged from highly amused to thoughtful or deeply critical of the Times.

“What is Buttigieg’s media diet such that he has never until this moment heard ‘Mayo Pete,'” Parker Higgins wondered.

Brittany L. Shepherd of Yahoo! News offered a more nuanced analysis. She pointed out that the nickname is indicative of problems Buttigieg has with not only young voters, but specifically young voters of color, and noted that while mayo is fun to laugh about, some young voters aren’t laughing at being disregarded by frontrunners like Buttigieg.

“Pete’s campaign has made a vested interest in HBCU youth outreach, dropped ads in Snapchat targeted at black teens, gathered young black surrogates from South Bend to travel with him!” she concluded. “But a worry is if the timing is too little too late. Of course, South Carolina will be a tell.”

The mayo references didn’t end there.

Later in the interview, Buttigieg shared his coming out story. When he finished, one of the interviews said that it “makes you less mayo.”

“Maybe. Hopefully a better flavor,” Buttigieg responded.

After one suggested perhaps the flavor was “basil mayo,” Buttigieg apparently decided to lean really hard into Mayo Pete.

“I actually hate flavored mayo,” he said. “…I only use mayo when I’m making tuna salad. And I want it as straightforward as possible.”

Asked if he was joking, because, as everyone knows, flavored mayonnaise is delicious, Buttigieg doubled down on plain mayonnaise.

“No, it’s high-protein,” he said. “It’s very affordable.”

The Times’ editorial board announces its endorsement on Jan. 19.


Share this article
*First Published: Jan 16, 2020, 1:05 pm CST