Jar Jar trounces Queen Amidala in troubling ‘Star Wars’ fan vote

This is deeply upsetting.

 

Aja Romano

Internet Culture

Published Mar 26, 2015   Updated May 29, 2021, 5:24 am CDT

It’s no secret that Jar Jar Binks is one of the most reviled characters in modern film history, let alone in Star Wars. He’s an obnoxious, heinously racist caricature who’s been the top spot (or bottom) on endless “worst character” lists. When his death video emerged in 2013, fans actually celebrated.

Featured Video Hide

So why is he pummeling Queen Amidala in the Star Wars March Madness competition?

Advertisement Hide

Star Wars Madness

Fans have been handwringing all day over the inexplicable beating that Padmé is taking against Jar Jar. Twitter has been more or less beside itself:

Advertisement Hide

https://twitter.com/Momyslove/status/581171306969731072

But not everyone was so quick to join the parade—despite a brief rally earlier in the day, Padmé is trailing further behind than ever. 

Advertisement Hide
(Sorry, this embed was not found.)

Advertisement Hide

https://twitter.com/CoryGallaher/status/581041873768325121

Over on Wookieepedia, where StarWars.com encouraged fans to create their own brackets, the hatred was even more pronounced.

"Jar Jar is life"

“Jar Jar is life”

Wookieepedia

As frequently happens with online polls, accusations have abounded that fans on Wookieepedia and 4chan have been running scripts to generate the results they want in the challenge. That would be nothing new. The trolls of /b/, 4chan’s infamous “random: subforum, once had Mountain Dew naming a new flavor after Hitler.

Advertisement Hide

Sure enough, over on 4chan, “Operation Jar Jar” was in full effect Thursday. The pranksters intended to make no-name Bib Fortuna and universally reviled Binks the two most popular characters in Star Wars history. The goal is to have these two face off in the final round. No Luke, no Vader, just Bib and Jar-Jar.

4chan.org

While the goal may just be to prank the results, it’s frustrating to see one of the only two main female characters in the entire franchise be subject to what looks like vote-rigging. So far in this first round, all of the female characters listed except Leia have lost—and she was paired off against another minor female character.

Advertisement Hide

Not only is the message being sent that fans would literally rather vote for a racist stereotype than a female character, but it’s coming at the worst possible time. Geek girls are already protesting the lack of women-oriented merchandise for the upcoming franchise reboot.

“It’s important because right now, it looks like no one appreciates or even likes the female characters in [Star Wars],” wrote becauseofloki on Tumblr. “And since this voting is taken at least a little bit seriously, it could mean that we don’t get much more than the few female characters we currently have.”

Advertisement Hide

Chin up, Star Wars fans. It appears StarWars.com is already weeding out the fake votes. Princess Leia faces off against R2-D2 in the next round, and if there’s anything that can send a message that girls in the fandom should be taken seriously, it’s watching our favorite overlooked Jedi Knight trounce everyone’s favorite droid.

This story has been updated with more information about 4chan’s raid.

Additional reporting by Luke Winkie.

Photo via inacentaurdump/Flickr (CC BY 2.0)

Share this article
*First Published: Mar 26, 2015, 8:14 pm CDT