- Southwest Airlines passengers receive free Nintendo Switch consoles and Mario Maker 2 Wednesday 9:10 PM
- The Deplorable Choir drops diss track aimed at 4 congresswomen from Trump’s racist tweets Wednesday 8:09 PM
- Florida city is pushing homeless people out by playing ‘Baby Shark’ on a loop Wednesday 7:27 PM
- A ‘Gossip Girl’ reboot is coming to HBO Max–and fans are not happy with the casting details Wednesday 6:44 PM
- Beto can’t leverage his slave owner ancestry to gain Black voters’ trust Wednesday 5:51 PM
- Oakland to become the third U.S. city to ban facial recognition Wednesday 5:50 PM
- ‘Release the Snyder Cut’ billboards pop up outside of San Diego Comic-Con Wednesday 5:24 PM
- Iggy Azalea and Peppa Pig have an epic Twitter fight Wednesday 4:39 PM
- Should you be concerned about your privacy on FaceApp? Wednesday 4:15 PM
- Google ‘terminates’ Dragonfly, its censored search engine for China Wednesday 3:33 PM
- AOC rips Facebook during Libra House hearing Wednesday 3:14 PM
- The time traveler conversation meme finds its way to TikTok Wednesday 2:52 PM
- Grimes claims she had an ‘experimental’ eye surgery and practices sword fighting Wednesday 2:42 PM
- 70 Border Patrol employees under investigation for posts in secret Facebook group Wednesday 1:45 PM
- Republican’s Operation Safe Return criticized as cover for mass deporation Wednesday 1:42 PM
Chris Hemsworth will return as Kirk’s dad in ‘Star Trek 4,’ but does he really need to?
There are already a million movies about heroes with daddy issues. Does ‘Star Trek’ really have to join them?
Hemsworth first appeared as George Kirk in 2009’s Star Trek, dying within minutes of his son’s birth. In the fourth film, Jim Kirk will apparently “cross paths” with his dead father, hinting ominously at a trope that plagues way too many movies. That’s right, it’s time for some daddy issues.
This leaves us wondering, where the heck are all the Space Moms?
In J.J. Abrams‘ Star Trek, George Kirk looms large. Jim lives in the shadow of his father’s legacy, a narrative decision that coincidentally erases Winona Kirk from existence. After giving birth to Jim in the middle of a space battle, her role in the franchise is over. Which is kind of weird, considering the fact that she raised Jim from birth.
Genre movies love daddy issues, but they’re consistently terrible at moms. With a handful of exceptions like Terminator‘s Sarah Connor, moms don’t get to be heroes. They rarely even get to be interesting. Though bonding over moms was a key turning point for Bruce Wayne and Clark Kent in Batman v Superman, Jonathan Kent and Jor-El loom far larger over the Superman franchise. Tony Stark‘s mom was functionally nonexistent until Captain America: Civil War. In the Dark Knight trilogy, Martha Wayne was a nice lady in the background while Thomas Wayne was an icon of Gotham city. As for Star Wars, a story whose father issues are far more complex, Padme Amidala fades into the background as Anakin’s legacy lives on.
It’s certainly possible that Jennifer Morrison’s Winona Kirk will appear in Star Trek 4 alongside Chris Hemsworth, but the previous movies don’t bode well. It’s a safe guess that we’re heading for the Daddy Issues Zone again.
This is just too bad, because both versions of Jim Kirk break the mold from the typical tragic hero backstory. In the reboot movies, the formative person in Jim’s childhood is a woman, and their relationship begs for further examination. Meanwhile in the original timeline, there’s every indication that Jim Kirk had a pretty normal upbringing—except for one live-changing event.
As a child, Kirk survived a famine on the colony Tarsus IV. To preserve their remaining supplies, the governor had half of the 8,000 colonists executed. As a staunch believer in eugenics (an ongoing theme in the early Star Trek stories) the governor personally decided which colonists should live, and which should die.
William Shatner’s Kirk was a lot less angsty than Chris Pine’s, but this backstory proves he wasn’t just the wholesome product of a nuclear family in Iowa. He went through a huge trauma as a child, and it shaped his political opinions and sense of empathy as an adult. It’s also a much more interesting story than rehashing the familiar trope of a hero coming to terms with his dead father’s legacy.
Basically, Star Trek 4 has a lot of options to work with. Let’s hope they don’t choose the most obvious one.
SEE ALSO: I watched classic Trek for the first time and loved it
Gavia Baker-Whitelaw is a staff writer at the Daily Dot, covering geek culture and fandom. Specializing in sci-fi movies and superheroes, she also appears as a film and TV critic on BBC radio. Elsewhere, she co-hosts the pop culture podcast Overinvested. Follow her on Twitter: @Hello_Tailor