- Trump complains about his Twitter follower count to Jack Dorsey Tuesday 6:34 PM
- ‘Avengers: Endgame’ sticks the devastating landing—and gives you time to grieve Tuesday 5:00 PM
- Teen hits Apple with $1 billion lawsuit over alleged face recognition arrest Tuesday 4:48 PM
- John Cornyn tried to attack Patton Oswalt for his old tweets and failed miserably Tuesday 4:29 PM
- Logan Paul is selling a pillow of his dead dog—for a good cause Tuesday 4:04 PM
- Study: Too much Netflix, not enough ‘chill’ Tuesday 3:36 PM
- Pete Buttigieg under fire for saying incarcerated Americans shouldn’t be allowed to vote Tuesday 2:54 PM
- Vine’s co-founder is beta testing a new app called Byte Tuesday 2:51 PM
- Report: Joe Biden’s first 2020 fundraiser will be with a Comcast executive Tuesday 2:49 PM
- Netflix’s ‘Sabrina’ appears to have an art-copying problem (updated) Tuesday 2:47 PM
- People are crying over these cats’ window-sill romance Tuesday 2:27 PM
- The ‘I’m baby’ meme is all about being comforted Tuesday 2:24 PM
- Parody video totally nails what men are like on Tinder Tuesday 1:57 PM
- Twitch star AriLove latest woman to be arbitrarily banned for ‘sexually suggestive’ attire Tuesday 1:47 PM
- The 18 best Korean beauty sheet masks Tuesday 1:25 PM
According to a former CIA agent who met with Edward Snowden, the whistleblower’s laptops didn’t contain any classified NSA information.
After former intelligence contractor Edward Snowden leaked a trove of secret U.S. National Security Agency surveillance documents to the Guardian, he fled to Hong Kong and, soon after, Russia. Throughout the trip, reports came in that as Snowden made his way through Asia, he was carrying four laptops. The assumption, at the time, was that the laptops contained the top-secret NSA files.
According to a Reuters report on Friday, the computers were, in fact, decoys.
Reuters based its conclusion on the statements of a former CIA agent who, had become critical of the U.S. mass online surveillance of emails, phone calls, chats, and videos that Snowden revealed.
The former agent, Ray McGovern, who was visiting Snowden to give him the “Integrity of Intelligence” award, told Reuters that not only were the laptops harmless diversions but that no top-secret information had been given to Russia or China.
McGovern also added that Snowden now lived under protection of what he thought was an official Russian security detail and that before his group met with the whistleblower, they had to pass through a metal detector.
That Snowden’s laptops were decoys is, in hindsight, rather obvious (and indeed some reporters speculated as much). Carrying classified data around the world on four computers would have been a curious choice in the age of thumbdrives.
However, the laptops are far from meaningless: The world’s willingness to believe that they were the vessel for Snowden’s classified documents betrays something about the way we engage with the Snowden narrative. Collectively, we were all too willing to buy into the idea that Snowden was a sort of Cold War-era spy (or double agent or hero) moving through Russia with his bundle of secret files. It’s an intoxicating story. Unfortunately, it’s also a distraction.
What the successful deception of the laptops reveals is that for many, the story of Edward Snowden, the man of secrets, the international fugitive, was not, in fact, about the NSA revelations. In other words, for many, it didn’t matter if the laptops were empty, because their interest didn’t rest in revelations the computers contained. Snowden’s story was simply an intoxicating tale of a man on the run from the most powerful intelligence community in the world.
You needn’t take my word for it; a simple Google Trends search reveals that for much of the time after Snowden revealed the existence of PRISM, the first and most well-known of his leaks, there was more interest in the whistleblower’s getaway than there was in the fact that the U.S. government used secret warrants to harvest the social media and email data of thousands of innocent American citizens:
Perhaps now we can focus on what we thought was in the laptops.
Photo by Kamyar Adl/Flickr
Joe Kloc is a former Daily Dot contributor who covered technology and policy. He's contributed to Newsweek and Mother Jones, discussed his reporting on air with WNYC, and written Weekly Reviews for Harper's Magazine.