- Ta-Nehisi Coates dismantles Mitch McConnell’s anti-reparations argument Wednesday 7:52 PM
- Whoopi Goldberg stirs debate over her opinion regarding Bella Thorne’s nudes Wednesday 7:04 PM
- Joe Biden really, really hates raves Wednesday 6:02 PM
- RIP to the Twitter geotagging feature that no one actually used Wednesday 5:14 PM
- Facebook contractors reveal the horrors of moderating graphic content Wednesday 4:42 PM
- Prosecutor almost directly quoted Bible in trial against man who helped migrants Wednesday 4:05 PM
- TikTok’s time warp videos get it twisted Wednesday 4:03 PM
- Is a ‘Stranger Things’ and Fortnite crossover event going to happen? Wednesday 3:55 PM
- YouTube reportedly thinking about moving all kids content off the main site Wednesday 3:50 PM
- AOC calls out Democrats for tone-deaf Beyoncé tweet Wednesday 3:15 PM
- Democrat candidates come out as ‘wife guys’ Wednesday 2:45 PM
- Poll of best Batman actors fails to include Adam West, and fans are not happy Wednesday 2:25 PM
- ‘Pose’ producer Janet Mock lands historic Netflix deal Wednesday 1:54 PM
- Teen confesses to killing her best friend on video to get $9 million from a stranger online Wednesday 1:28 PM
- Democrats vote to block transgender troop ban Wednesday 12:17 PM
Conservatives attack Rep. Ilhan Omar over Notre Dame condolences
Fibonacci Blue/Flickr (CC-BY)
Conservatives became angry that Rep. Ilhan Omar did not acknowledge the religious significance as a Christian place of worship in her tweet.
Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) was subject to vitriol on Monday in response to tweeting her condolences following the fire that engulfed Paris’ Notre Dame Cathedral.
The lawmaker posted that she was “praying” for those trying to save the building at reflected on “art and architecture” as a unifying force.
Art and architecture have a unique ability to help us connect across our differences and bring people together in important ways. Thinking of the people of Paris and praying for every first responder trying to save this wonder.
— Ilhan Omar (@IlhanMN) April 15, 2019
Many conservatives became angry that Omar did not acknowledge the cathedral’s name or its religious significance as a Christian place of worship in her tweet.
Well, the “architecture” that the art was housed in is a cathedral. While Biblically Christ is wherever His people are, Notre Dame is a significant and storied icon of faith. https://t.co/bsckz26qHe
— Dana Loesch (@DLoesch) April 16, 2019
"Art and architecture"?! Is that all the Notre Dame Cathedral is in your mind?
— Joseph Steinberg (@JosephSteinberg) April 16, 2019
Amazing you found a way to phrase this without saying “Notre Dame,” “cathedral,” or “church.”
— Angela Morabito (@AngelaLMorabito) April 16, 2019
She just can't bring herself to say it's a church. It's a huge symbol for Christianity but we all know why she can't say it…. a total disgrace https://t.co/LwxHIQSmde
— Melissa Mederos (@Mel_Med_) April 16, 2019
The outrage builds on the conservative response to comments made by the Muslim lawmaker during a speech to the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) about the 9/11 terror attacks that some perceived as insensitive—a note that “some people did something.”
In response to Omar’s Notre Dame tweet, many made joking parallel reference to the 9/11 remarks.
Someone did something somewhere in France
— ChooseJesus (@ChooseJesus1) April 15, 2019
Some art and architecture “burned or something” and that is bad.
— threat.level.midnight (@stevengorney) April 15, 2019
For some on the right, however, the criticism escalated to attacks on the lawmaker which drew links between her Muslim faith and even, in one case, the actions of Islamist terror group ISIS.
A Christian Church burns and she is concerned about art and architecture. I wonder if that would be her take if Mecca burned. https://t.co/PmiASpqt94
— Carmine Sabia (@CarmineSabia) April 15, 2019
How to identify a hard-core Islamist 👇 https://t.co/uhDSIwzr47
— Patla Aaloo🥔 (@lexbery) April 16, 2019
The Cathedral containing the Crown of Thorns is just “art and architecture” to @IlhanMN. This is the same flippant attitude towards the sacred that ISIS displayed when destroying Palmyra. https://t.co/2V6FYboIj2
— Raheem Kassam (@RaheemKassam) April 15, 2019
Some liberals were quick to respond in the Minnesota lawmaker’s defense, acknowledging there’s little she can do right when some on the right appear to lie in wait for her to make a slip.
Ilhan: “I had toast for breakfast.”
Ridiculous Right: “omfg she is totally disrespecting breakfast as the most important meal of the day this is a clear attack on everything America stands for she should be deported back to Somalia where they hate breakfast!”
— David Lawrence (@fidgitNZ) April 16, 2019
This is crazy. Ilhan Omar wrote a sympathetic tweet about Notre Dame and, in response, got compared to ISIS. 1,800 retweets. https://t.co/LatunToKka
— Matt Pearce 🦅 (@mattdpearce) April 16, 2019
Omar has always been a target for those on the right, as a Democrat, but what motivates this narrative comes across a little more sinister, a kind of cumulative evidencing of the manufactured notion that because of her faith the lawmaker holds active “contempt” for Western values and other faiths.
And it has no end in sight.
David Gilmour is a reporter who specializes in national politics, internet culture, and technology. He previously covered civil liberties, crime, and politics for Vice.