Pose’s Indya Moore goes viral for arguing trans women have ‘biologically female’ penises

MTVNews/YouTube

Trans women’s genitals are women’s genitals, period.

Pose’s Indya Moore isn’t backing down when it comes to trans people’s bodies.

Moore, a trans actress of color who plays transgender sex worker Angel Evangelista on Pose, has long used her platform on social media to speak openly about trans lives. Last weekend, she went viral over a series of tweets, which started with a simple statement: “Trans women are biological women.”

Throughout the day she expanded on the point, explaining that not all women have XX chromosomes, that gender and sex aren’t one and the same, and that a woman’s gender shouldn’t be defined based on whether she can become pregnant or not. Each of those stereotypes harm trans and cis women alike, forcing them to confine to narrow boxes that simply do not reflect how gender is experienced in the world.

“The biology of trans women may be different than that of a cis woman, but that doesn’t make trans women less biological, less woman, or less biological women,” Moore wrote. “Trans women aren’t synthetic or parody women. Ya’ll support trans women up until it gets real.” (The Daily Dot reached out to Moore for comment and is awaiting a response.)

Moore took the often-heard rallying cry “trans women are women” one step further: She argued that if trans women are biological women, by definition, a trans woman’s penis is “a biologically female penis.” That’s a radical point missing in mainstream discussions on trans bodies, as trans women are often made to feel as if they should be ashamed of their genitals if they don’t have a vagina.

“A biologically female penis is a non artificial penis (eg: dildo, vibrator,) that is part of a biological (human) woman’s body,” she explained.

Moore also criticized an Out magazine article on masturbation tips “for girls who need to get off” that solely focused on cisgender women’s bodies. Out later pledged to “rework” the piece, and its headline now reads “23 Masturbation Tips for People With Vaginas.”

When reached for comment, an Out spokesperson stressed the piece “will either be revised or entirely recreated to not assume that all women have vaginas.”

“This was an error at the time this piece was assigned and promoted on social media, which predates Out’s new editorial team’s arrival,” the Out spokesperson told the Daily Dot. “In short, Out’s sex content moving forward will and should talk about vaginal and clitoral stimulation without assuming a person’s gender identity. It’s so important that Out—and all outlets, really—create educational sex content that’s inclusive of various bodies and identities.”

“We regret the error,” the spokesperson continued, “and while we work on the next steps for this particular piece, we, of course, look forward to creating more (and more inclusive!) content about sexual health and pleasure.”

With Moore’s viral tweets—her original Saturday post sparked over 4,000 retweets and 20,000 likes—she is forcing cisgender Twitter users to address their hidden biases against trans bodies. By stressing trans women are biological women, Moore is arguing that trans women exist as women innately and deserve to be treated as women regardless of whether they adhere to cisgender conceptions of womanhood.

In other words, it’s not enough to simply stand behind trans people and respect their pronouns. Cis people must embrace trans people in all of their physical configurations, from non-op trans women with penises to trans men that refuse testosterone and top surgery.

Oh, and the world needs way, way more guides on masturbation for trans folks.

“I or someone else should really create masturbation tips for trans people with penises/clitorises/vaginas,” Moore tweeted. “[Especially] being that this Cisiety makes it hard for us to have healthy relationships with our bodies/body parts.”

Editor’s note: This piece has been updated to include comment from Out.

Ana Valens

Ana Valens

Ana Valens is a reporter specializing in online queer communities, marginalized identities, and adult content creation. She is Daily Dot's Trans/Sex columnist. Her work has appeared at Waypoint, Truthout, Bitch Media, Kill Screen, Rolling Stone's Glixel, and the Toast. She lives in Brooklyn, New York.