59yo John Schnatter is seen winking at 21yo actress Paige Madison Evans

John Schnatter / TikTok

‘Did anyone else feel violated?’ Papa John’s founder called ‘creepy’ for flirty video with young TikToker

'What did I just watch.'


Samira Sadeque

Internet Culture

Published May 20, 2021   Updated Jun 1, 2021, 2:23 pm CDT

The Papa John’s founder is being dragged online for his flirtatious TikTok duet with a Canadian actress, who is 38 years younger than him. 

Featured Video Hide

John Schnatter, who is 59 years old, posted duetted actress Paige Madison Evans, 21, on TikTok in April. 

Advertisement Hide

In Madison’s original video, posted in March, Evans reenacts a scene from the Fleabag.

“Don’t flirt with him,” the audio says as Evans mouths along.  

“I am not going to flir-,” Evans “says,” not finishing the sentence because she presumably she sees a man, who is out of the camera’s view. In the original video, she goes on to shake herself off and says, “Fucking hell.” 

Schnatter then duetted her video, pretending to be the man she is stunned by. His portion of the video begins with only the backside of his chair showing. He then turns his chair around to reveal his presence to Evans before striking a flirty expression: nodding his head and winking.

Advertisement Hide

People commented on the post, calling it everything from “creepy” and “sad” to “saucy.” While the video was posted in April, much of the criticism was posted in May.

“Why would you do this to that poor child?” wrote one user. 

“Wow. that’s sad,” wrote another. 

“’What did I just watch,” a third questioned. 

Advertisement Hide

“Did anyone else feel violated when he winked?” another asked, per the Daily Mail.

However, Evans, herself, seems to find Schnatter’s duet endearing. “Omg hey papa,” she commented on his duet the same day he posted it.

“Thanks for enjoying a laugh and having a sense of humor!” he responded on Wednesday, almost two months after she commented. 

His video has garnered 2.4 million views so far—exceeding the usual number of views he gets on his TikTok content. 

Today’s top stories

TikToker exposes nurse’s ‘hateful’ videos, allegedly gets him fired
‘Of course people are going to break down under these conditions’: Viral photo of McDonald’s worker’s ‘quitting’ sign sparks debate
Karen almost ‘ruins’ beach proposal in viral TikTok
Sign up to receive the Daily Dot’s Internet Insider newsletter for urgent news from the frontline of online.

Share this article
*First Published: May 20, 2021, 8:49 pm CDT