- ‘Carole and Tuesday’ is a feast for the eyes, ears, and heart 4 Years Ago
- Tara Booth’s Instagram art embraces the comedy in mental health struggles 4 Years Ago
- Everything we know so far about Peacock, NBC’s new streaming service Tuesday 7:42 PM
- Selena Gomez producing docuseries about immigration for Netflix Tuesday 7:11 PM
- How to stream Manchester City vs. Shakhtar Donetsk in Champions League action Tuesday 6:14 PM
- Milo Yiannopoulos threatens to crash furry convention he is barred from Tuesday 5:54 PM
- How to stream Juventus vs. Atletico Madrid in Champions League action Tuesday 5:52 PM
- How to stream Real Madrid vs. PSG in Champions League action Tuesday 5:24 PM
- No-fly zone implemented over Area 51 ahead of Alienstock festival Tuesday 5:16 PM
- TikTok accused of censoring content about Hong Kong protests Tuesday 5:04 PM
- Smoke ’em, pass ’em, Week 3: At the Bakery Tuesday 4:38 PM
- Alex Trebek says he will be undergoing chemotherapy again Tuesday 4:27 PM
- Dan Crenshaw roasted after attacking Sanders’ call for veteran care Tuesday 4:19 PM
- How to stream NXT for its USA network debut Tuesday 4:12 PM
- This website will show you how AI classifies you Tuesday 3:22 PM
In a new twist on the #FreeTheNipple movement, James Shamsi decided to do an experiment to test the boundaries of what Instagram deems an appropriate nipple. He posted a random photo on Instagram that he found online of a bare-chested man with areolae larger that the typical male’s. In other words, nipples that more closely resembled those of a woman. Then he put out a call to his Facebook friends to help him test a theory.
“I saw a lot of posts recently about #FreeTheNipple by friends, so I started looking into it just this week,” Shamsi told the Daily Dot via email. “Soon enough I realized Instagrams (and societies) policies are still a little archaic when it comes to the perception of the Human chest. So, I wanted to see for myself and prove to Instagram just how silly their policies are.”
That’s when he came up with the idea to see if Instagram would have the audacity to take down a post that was actually not violating any of its policies. “They should hopefully see how daft and over sexualized the entire thing is,” he said.
Shamsi posted the photo, and just as he expected, it was subsequently taken down after multiple users reported it.
#FREETHENIPPLE. Instagram allows male nipples, but not female. I wanted to show them how stupid this policy is, so I did a little experiment… I uploaded the picture on the top right, the full form of which you can see on the bottom right. The nipples are all male. However, within 2 hours the photo was taken down by Instagram because they thought it was female. I’ve emailed them to dispute this, and explained why I did the experiment. Hopefully this will go someway in showing how ridiculous Instagrams policies are. Cheers, James
A photo posted by James Shamsi (@jamesshamsi) on
Shamsi is no stranger to using social networks to prove a point or find an alternative use for it. In September of last year, he posted his résumé on Tinder—and it actually worked. After graduating college in London and moving to Los Angeles, he realized he need connections to get a job. And after sharing his work experience on the popular dating app, he ended up with multiple job offers.
This isn’t the first experiment to test Facebook and Instagram’s boundaries. Artist Micol Hebron created a campaign last year where she asked women to post topless photos of themselves with a stock photo of a male nipple pasted over their own.
Many Instagram users joined in on the experiment, and their photos have not yet been taken down by community managers, illustrating to many a double-standard.
A photo posted by Dylan Bianco (@dydou._) on
When reached for comment, an Instagram spokesperson said the company is “looking into this.”
Update Aug. 20, 2:24pm: Instagram reinstated James Shamsi’s photo. The company did not provide any additional clarification about its policy or the decision.
A photo posted by James Shamsi (@jamesshamsi) on
Update Aug. 20, 4:56pm: An Instagram spokesperson provided the Daily Dot with the following statement.
“Standards around nudity vary greatly by culture, country, age, and other factors. Our goal has always been to find a balance between enabling people to express themselves, while also making sure that our large, diverse, global community feels comfortable. Striking the right balance is hard – and examples like this highlight the complexity of this issue. As always, we continue to analyze our policies to make sure that we’re listening to people and meeting the needs of our global community.”
Photo via osseous/Flickr (CC BY 2.0) | Remix by Jason Reed
Marisa Kabas is a lifestyle reporter and activist. Her work has been published by Fusion, Fast Company, and Today. She’s also served as an editorial campaigns director for Purpose PBC, a social movement incubator.