Tumblarity is back—and unpopular as ever

In 2009, the Tumblr community feared Tumblarity would result in a vicious popularity contest. The site listened.


Fernando Alfonso III


Published Jul 19, 2013   Updated Jun 1, 2021, 11:03 am CDT

When Tumblr released Tumblarity, its analytics feature, in May 2009, the community feared it would result in a vicious popularity contest, shifting focus away from quality to working the system for more followers. The site listened: About six months later, Tumblarity was shut down.

Featured Video Hide


Advertisement Hide

On Thursday, Tumblr released “Tumblarity 2.0,” a pared-down version that allows users to track their follower count and notes. The latest feature, simply called Analytics, gives users insight into who follows them. But many just want it to disappear.


“Analytics are cool, but I feel like this will make me care more about numbers than self expression,” sethpalmer3 blogged

Advertisement Hide

Other users on Tumblr have argued that Analytics negatively affects users self-esteem and lets them know how “unpopular” they are.

Tumblr debuted the new feature on its staff blog Thursday, the same day it came under scrutiny for aggressively removing blogs flagged as “NSFW” or “Adult” from general searches and censoring tags like “gay,” “bisexual,” and “lesbian” from its mobile app. 

The release of the Analytics feature happened roughly two days after Union Metrics, Tumblr’s official analytics partner, rolled out its own free statistics option that is similar to Tumblarity. 


Advertisement Hide

The following screengrabs are from users criticizing the new Analytics feature. 

via ryanmcevoy

Advertisement Hide


via spexigt


Advertisement Hide

via reveling


Advertisement Hide

via ididliterallynothingtoday


Advertisement Hide

via cryingmonsters


Illustration by Fernando Alfonso III

Share this article
*First Published: Jul 19, 2013, 11:32 am CDT