- Daniel Caesar dons cape for whiteness—and gets canceled Wednesday 4:29 PM
- Triton is a new malware ‘deliberately’ designed to put lives at risk Wednesday 3:23 PM
- ‘Into the Dark: I’m Just F*cking with You’ is one of the series’ best Wednesday 1:54 PM
- Trump’s latest prop, a map of ISIS, gets memed Wednesday 12:54 PM
- HBO sends fans on a global scavenger hunt for 6 Iron Thrones Wednesday 11:51 AM
- The Awkward Family Photos game is Cards Against Humanity for meme lovers Wednesday 11:50 AM
- London firefighters’ organization accuses ‘Peppa Pig’ of sexism Wednesday 11:41 AM
- YouTuber accused of abusing her children to make kid-friendly content Wednesday 11:20 AM
- Ari Fleischer’s Iraq War tweet isn’t going over well Wednesday 10:54 AM
- Cop arrested for recording man’s genitals, forcing mentally ill man to twerk Wednesday 10:37 AM
- MoviePass rebrands its unlimited plan, again Wednesday 10:37 AM
- Former Alaska senator launches meme-filled 2020 primary campaign Wednesday 10:17 AM
- The Shane Dawson cat controversy has resulted in these sex memes Wednesday 10:06 AM
- Sarah Sanders mocks CNN reporter with ‘dear diary’ tweet Wednesday 9:03 AM
- Know what you’re signing up for thanks to these dating site reviews Wednesday 8:58 AM
AT&T’s shady way of sneaking ads into free Wi-Fi hotspots might be illegal
This is the price of free Wi-Fi
Jonathan Mayer, a computer scientist and lawyer at Stanford, first reported on the issue on his blog, Web Policy, after noticing odd ads popping up on his university’s website. Other sites already supported by ad placement were inundated with additional banners and popups that didn’t appear to be associated with the site itself.
All of the additional advertisements being pushed into the browser experience, Mayer found, were from AT&T. Some additional digging revealed that the service provider was injecting ads into unsecured HTTP traffic with a platform provided by network monetization startup RaGaPa. In short, AT&T is monetizing its “free” Wi-Fi hotspots.
When a person who is connected to AT&T’s hotspot attempts to navigate to an HTTP webpage, the hotspot makes three edits. First, it adds an advertising stylesheet to host the popup, then it creates a backup advertisement, and employs two scripts that pull advertising content from third-party providers and pushes in front of the webpage content.
AT&T’s terms of service provided to users who connect with the company’s hotspots makes no mention of injected advertising, which gives the user no opportunity to opt out of the experience. The advertisements are also unmarked, so the origin of them are obscured.
The act of injecting ads isn’t explicitly illegal, though Mayer suggests there are plenty of rules that strongly discourage it. Under the Federal Communications Commission’s (FCC) net neutrality rules, it would have to be shown that the ads in question are “unreasonably interfering with” or “unreasonably disadvantaging” consumer or website connectivity.
If AT&T is routing traffic through servers hosted by RaGaPa, Mayer suggests that wiretapping statutes could come into effect, though he did not test to find if the traffic was being directed in such a way.
AJ Dellinger is a seasoned technology writer whose work has appeared in Digital Trends, International Business Times, and Newsweek. In 2018, he joined Gizmodo as the nights and weekend editor.