Senior Homeland Security official says Internet anonymity should be outlawed

encrypt lock 2
'Should not every individual be required to display a ‘license plate’ on the digital super-highway?'

A senior Homeland Security official recently argued that Internet anonymity should outlawed in the same way that driving a car without a license plate is against the law.

Erik Barnett, an assistant deputy director at U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and attache to the European Union at the Department of Homeland Security, outlined his argument in an article titled “Whose Privacy Are We Protecting? Balancing Rights to Anonymity with Rights to Public Safety,” published in FIC Observatory, a French publication dedicated to debates about cybersecurity.

To support his case, Barnett first told the story of sexually explicit photos of a Romanian infant girl being passed around on the Internet last year, a case that led to an arrest in a matter of weeks because the offender was not anonymous.

“Should not every individual be required to display a ‘license plate’ on the digital super-highway?”

Barnett asked how much data law enforcement and intelligence agencies should be able to examine from the likes of child abusers or jihadists.

“When a person drives a car on a highway, he or she agrees to display a license plate,” Barnett wrote. “The license plate’s identifiers are ignored most of the time by law enforcement. Law enforcement will use the identifiers, though, to determine the driver’s identity if the car is involved in a legal infraction or otherwise becomes a matter of public interest. Similarly, should not every individual be required to display a ‘license plate’ on the digital super-highway?”

The suggestion yielded backlash quickly. Nate Cardozo, a staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, called the idea “plainly unconstitutional.”

Barnett's essay didn't offer much in the way of specifics. Instead, he asked a number of provocative questions. He also briefly considered the other side of the argument, conceding that digital “reveals much more personal information than would normally be found in physical evidence at a crime scene.”

Photo via Mark Fischer/Flickr (CC by 2.0) | Remix by Max Fleishman

Promoted Stories Powered by Sharethrough
Layer 8
A female Lebanese news anchor was told to shut up—here's what she did instead
Rima Karaki is a Lebanese TV host who isn't afraid of a fight. Things got heated Monday when Karaki was interviewing Hani Al-Seba'i about the phenomenon of Christians joining Islamic groups like ISIS. Al-Seba’i is a Sunni scholar who fled to London after he was sentenced in an Egyptian court to 15 years in prison for being a part of the Egyptian Islamic Jihad. The United Nations considers the group to be an affiliate of al Qaeda.
anonymity
Facebook lets Android users access the app anonymously through Tor
Facebook 's popular Android app now supports use by the Tor anonymity network. The new feature will make it easier to securely access the world's most popular social network on the world's most popular smartphone operating system.
The Latest From Daily Dot Video
Group

Pure, uncut internet. Straight to your inbox.

Thanks for subscribing to our newsletter!